Jeet By Jersey

820 E 116th St #130, Carmel, IN 46032, USA

Address:	820 E 116th St #130, Carmel, IN 46032, USA
Phone:	+1 317-580-1400
Site:	jerseyscafe.com
Rating:	4.2
Working:	11AM–3PM 11AM–8PM 11AM–8PM 11AM–8PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM Closed

Location

Photos 20

Reviews 33

Keith Smith

This was one of the worst experiences that my wife and I had! We requested a table away from the trash container and coke machine the waitress was extremely rude as she said the table in the back are dirty you can sit here, I again I request a table in the back area, she said, that means I will have to clean a table as she rolled her eyes. I said we can wait, we drove 35 min to eat here. She made a comment again and had an attitude about cleaning the dirty table as she walked away and we walked out. Well the experience that “Triple D” had on his show was not what we had experienced.

Carrie Wehlage

I would have given this place 5 stars if not for one thing. I ordered my sandwich without onions, and it was if I had committed a crime. The cook came out and asked if I was the one who ordered the sandwich without onions, I said yes, and he said I would have never made it on the East coast. They would have put onions on my sandwich anyway. So onions dont agree with me and I would rather not be sick the rest of the day because he thinks I should have onions. I was a little taken back by this as seemed pretty unprofessional. Other than that, everything was great

Kevin Young

Jeets is a great sandwich shop. The steaks are numerous and delicious. Ive had the Philly and the Wildwood and was happy with both. The hoagies look good. They are serious about the mustard in their mustard potato salad, so be aware. (Its good but might be too much for you if you dont love mustard.) Some items on the menu take longer to prepare than others (but are worth the wait,) so ask if youre short on time.

Philip Weeks

Great Chef & Great Service everytime! I guarantee youll find something you like but I would suggest anything on the menu or Chefs new creations! The Reggie is a staple and most peoples favorite, Wildwood, Loaded Chips are a must, Eli is awesome with the fried egg, the MOAB was stellar (not on the menu), the Rach is another good option. You really cant go wrong with anything on this menu.

Paul Marsh

I work here in Carmel and one of my favorite go to lunch places is Jeets! The food is always amazing. Hot, fresh, and made to order. I have never had a bad meal there. Best Sandwiches in Hamilton County hands down. I can personally recommend their Rubens and their Famous Wildwood Cheese Steak is amazing! If you are in Carmel, IN and are looking for a deli lunch this is the place to go.

Daniel friedman

Pretty damn good, I had the bacon cheesesteak and it was yummy. 2nd visit Im trying the Reggie. Ill let you know how I is. Great little place seems mom and popish, takes a little while to get your food but thats how you know its good. Because its just a little family restaurant. I like it.

Jane Fetch

I will never eat from this place again. I ordered the bacon cheesesteak and there was barely any steak on the sandwich. I saw this place on diners, drive inns, and dives, and they put so much meat on the steak sandwiches. Better to make myself next time. One star thats it

Jeremy Abbott

Would give 3.5* if I could. Service was great during lunch rush. I loved the flavor of the Philly, but was disappointed by the meat-to-bread-to-price ratio. Seemed to really skimp on the meat for some reason. The chicken salad sandwich was great.

Colin King

The food was good. The service is very slow, over an hour to get a sandwich. One server for the entire restaurant on a Saturday. As much as I like the food I just cant justify going back because of the extremely long wait time.

Lori Heise

Loved the chicken salad club sandwich which included tasty bacon, just the right amount of mayo, Swiss cheese, tomato, and peas! The rest of the family thoroughly enjoyed "The Reggie" and the BLT. We will definitely return!

kevin riley

Being from Jersey I wanted to go there since I seen it on the food chanel. Went last night and was not disappointed sandwiches were big and very tasty. The owners made you feel right at home will be going back again

April Homburg

Been fans of jerseys (jeets) for a long time now. You can never go wrong with their Loaded Chips; best Ive had on a consistent basis. Also no matter your taste you should find multiple sandwich options to your liking

L Klutzke

Always a lot of food for the money. Service is always super friendly and the food outstanding. Today tried their special. Best taco salad ever. Wife tends to get the huge BLT every time now because it is so good.

Daniel F

Awesome food, takes a little while to get it, but totally worth the wait. I heard if you order a philly without onions or cheese the chef comes out and yells at you. But i cannot verify. Very good sandwiches.

John Wright

It appears people are dissatisfied with the service. Probably because the staff were busy yelling at some cyclists for parking in the lot which was empty. We are Upland patrons. We will not be going to Jeets.

Christina Marcolini

This place is awesome. Great food, great service. Make sure you are not in a hurry or ask the staff which menu items take less time to prepare. Excellence cant be hurried..

Michael Henney

Great cheesesteaks and salads. Hoagies pretty darn good as well. Be prepared to wait on the chef to cook your meal. Not some fast food place! Much better!

Andrew Piera

Its like going back to NJ! Great subs and fries. Grab some Taylor Ham or Scrapple to take home. Eat her when ever I am on this side of Indy.

Imran Arain

Food was good but the wait was incredibly long especially at lunchtime. This will have to be an order ahead kind of place from now on.

Willie Brown

Fantastic service and the "loaded chips" were exquisite (if chips can be described as such)!

Bert Witte

Eh, slow service. Portion on the small side for the price. All ala cart. Not very impressed.

Jay Bilunas

Had the Turkey Club. Great simple sandwich. I love this place.

Matt Johnson

Awesome, fresh made sandwiches that are worth the wait.