NY PIZZA PIE
| Address: | 2589 Ogden Ave, Downers Grove, IL 60515, USA |
| Phone: | +1 331-777-9981 |
| Site: | nypizzapie4u.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | 5–9PM 11AM–2PM 11AM–2PM 11AM–2PM 11AM–2PM 2–9PM Closed |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 17
ST
Stuart Conover
Im on the fence here if I should give the pizza place 3 or 4 stars and 3.5 wasnt an option. ... I ordered NY Pizza Pie for delivery, wanting to try a new pizza spot as were looking for a second place to regularly order pizza from to mix it up from our main spot. The good: price, delivery times, and flavor of pizza. The macaroni bite flavor. Very friendly delivery driver. The okay: I mentioned above that the pizza tasted good but I felt that they massively skimped on the toppings for pepperoni and black olives. The Caesar salad was good, but the lettuce was wet when we got it. Not bad for immediate flavor but it meant it couldnt be split so half of it could be eaten later. The bad: The french fries looked like they should be crisp but were a bit mushy, not soggy from grease, just mushy. On top of that I tried an order of the garlic parm wings and they werent that flavorful. The sauce was more oil at the bottom of the container and even dipping the chicken in you didnt get much of it. I honestly really enjoyed the crust and the pizza with what toppings were given. May try them again but Im not really sure yet.
A
A Private User
The kids they have working are irresponsible and pack the wings the way they feel. The greasy wings leaked and the bag was soaked with grease. As I contacted Mike who is the owner, he basically told me to go screw myself and that he would do nothing to resolve the fact that my back seat was greased, my wifes jacket, slacks, and $500 purse was ruined by their irresponsibility. As I enjoy the wings, I will get my wings from other western suburb locations. This location at the end, doesnt care once you walk out their door. I will be contacting corporate, but I expect the same response. Stop rewarding bad service with business... find another wing place.
AD
Adam Kemp
We have been going to NY Pizza Pie multiple times a week since we moved our office to Lisle. I usually get two slices and the daily 99 cent appetizer special. Second slice for lunch the next day. Very friendly staff, bargain prices, and excellent slices with organic ingredients. Try the New York Minute or chorizo pizza. The only downside is that the amazing brat bites got discontinued by their supplier, but they can hardly be faulted for that. I used to own a pizza franchise of my own. If I could do it all over again, I would love to have franchised one of these.
KE
Keyon Badakhshanian
Went in with my girlfriend, loved the pizza, loved the cheese curds. They were amazing! We will definitely be back for the friendly service, and the organic food...and of course to try the Mac N Cheese Balls. We loved the chalk board you could draw on as well. Just a chill quick place to grab some good food. ONE LAST THING! The 2 slices with a drink for $7 is a steal! You can also take a picture with the little Italian man and share it to get an instant 10% off! Loving it.
IG
Ignas Rolskis
I ordered a 12" pizza to go from here with a side of onion straws. It was a bit expensive for the size in my opinion but tasted pretty good in flavor. They sell pizza by the slice so this would be a good place to go for lunch (which they arent usually open for unfortunately.) Last time I visited the pizzas on display for slices looked like theyve been sitting for a while and didnt look very fresh. Staff was very friendly.
PH
Phillip Green
Size of slice was amazing for the price. Good variety. As far as taste goes, I am picky with my pizza so for lunch it is adequate. I would mark it as 4 stars but they need to be more germ conscience. The person handling money and credit card was also handling pizza. Which is fine, but she touched both of my slices. Start using latex gloves after you finish the money transaction and I would adjust my rating.
JE
Jeremy Tregler
Really sad to see this location go. We drove by tonight for wings (ie. to make a "wing stop") and a sign on the door said this location had permanently closed. The closest location is now half an hour away. Im not sure Ill be able to visit very often, but I will miss this place. Best fast-style wing in the area, by far. Better quality than Hooters or Buffalo Wild Wings. It reminded me of Florida.
SH
Shanita Walker
Very disappointed. The supposed famous mac n cheese bites were very underwhelming; taste like nothing more than Kraft Dinner and very small(3 very tiny pieces for $4. I wish I could post a picture it was a joke) for the price. The wings taste like nothing more than fried chicken with hot sauce splashed on them; for the price I have had better. I have had the pizza and at least that was good.
JO
Joey DiVito
Good place, great food. Minus 1 star for the seating arrangement. Everyone sits facing the wall and I cant see my friends when theres more than 3 of us. Im just talking to the wall. Put a table at the front near the windows and unbolt that table along the wall in the back; pull it forward and add chairs so you can seat 6-8 people there facing each other. Theres room for it too. Great food.
JE
Jen Osyp
Update: The owner was very kind and covered the cost of my next order for the mistake & made sure the next order was correct!!! Very awesome! The pizza was great! Original post: ordered the BBQ CHICKEN pizza... while it was tasty, there were only 3 tiny half inch cubes of chicken and barely any BBQ sauce. I also ordered cheese curds, which were very good.
DA
Dan Stegmaier
Be sure to check out their specials. You can find some really good deals. Its nice to have a new pizza place around that is different from the rest. Theyve got some unique menu options and Id recommend the garlic knots. For pizza, the White Delight is my goto. The staff is friendly and really caters to their customers.
GR
Greta An
Im not a huge pizza fan but this place got me coming for more. Delicious pizza crust and whats even better you can see them baking it! Toppings are organic which is a great plus and pricing is decent. Little casual place located in suburbs thats definitely worth visiting!
BE
Ben Sell
Went in to try a slice the other day. Caught a glimpse of the employees balling up pizza dough in the back. Dough is definitely hand made, which is cool, and I could taste the difference. Would recommend to anyone who loves pizza pies made from scratch!
BR
Brain Rogers
Have been here a few times, I like them better than most places you can get wings and the more laid back atmosphere is a major plus. Prices are fair and the wings are way bigger than B-Dubs, also no puking college kids to deal with.
SA
Savarra C.
Flavor is good and toppings are fresh, but the crust is too thick and so is the rest of the dough. When we first tried it a year ago or more, the dough and crust were much thinner and was actually new York style. Disappointed.
JA
James Hensley
Staff is super friendly, will make pizza just about any way you like, the specialty pizzas are awesome, (make sure to try the teriyaki tango one) and the side items are good too (macaroni and cheese bites). Excellent value.
GU
Gustavo Dominguez
I came here last week and was immediately sold. Just came back again today. This place uses awesome ingredients to make pizza and it definitely tastes like it. I will keep coming here whenever I crave pizza. Love it!!!!
