The Plum Tomato, Salem, CT
| Address: | 1 New London Rd, Salem, CT 06420, USA |
| Phone: | +1 860-892-5295 |
| Site: | theplumtomato.com |
| Rating: | 4.1 |
| Working: | 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–9PM |
Location
Photos 52
Reviews 25
RE
Rebecca Benitez
We went in just to check it out & the guys were super friendly! We told them we were going to work up an appetite & they said they hoped we will come back, theyd be waiting for us. Very good energy, definitely made us curious. Their menu is pretty extensive & rather creative with the toppings & the item names, they offer gluten-free options as well. We did go back a little while later & ordered a large "The Godfather" (Mozzarella, pepperoni, & yummy sausage) to go, but ate a slice before we left while it was hot. Gotta give props to the sauce & crust - both fresh & the crust had the crunch. Imperfectly shaped, letting you know each is handmade. We had a bit of a situation where our pizza had to be remade, the manager handled the situation very well (much better than expected) & went above & beyond. One of the guys was his first day - he was very friendly & while helping a few customers, gave the appearance he had been there for a while.. not like a first day. I made sure to tell him & he was very appreciative. All 3 of the guys were smiling & gave very good Customer Service - something that makes good food taste better! The only real drawback is that its small! When we originally went in, there was no way Id consider eating in. As long as there really isnt anyone else in there we will, otherwise itll definitely be to-go. We cant wait to eat there again!! :-)
RO
Rosemarie Wilson
Have been eating pizza from this place frequently for years. Always thought it was some of the best around. Its August 13, 2017 and we just finished the fourth lousy pizza in a row. Ordered half TPT and half white with fresh tomato, peppers, mushrooms, and onion. The veggie half had lots of tomatoes, a few mushrooms, and 2 pieces of onion; no peppers at all. Plus there was meat on every slice of the no-meat half and not very much on the meat half. Seriously? Burnt on the bottom, yet soggy crust dripping with oil. Probably our last Plum Tomato pizza. Yuk!
JA
Javier Urtubia
This place rocks!... I am a huge pizza snob! I grew up in NYC so for me to like it it has to be good. The dough in and of its self is OK, but overall the pizza is really good. But if you are going to go to the plum dont go for the pizza!.. go for the Sammy the Bull! Trust me you will not be disappointed. They make these sandwiches using pizza dough as the bread.. whoever thought of this is a genius! its one of the best sandwiches I have ever eaten!
A
A Private User
October 9th 2011, I checked for restaurants nearby the Dinosaur Place and this place was listed online. Do not expect to find what you see on their website, very misleading. This place has only 4 small tables, there isnt even the bathroom or a faucet to wash your hands, the nearest bathroom is across the street at the gas station. Food comes very fast. Good and abundant fast food to take out. Staff is very friendly.
LE
Lee D
The pizza is amazing. NY style. The best in the area. I definitely will come again and recommend it. However, it didnt get 5 stars because of (minor for me but heads up to others) a lack of seating for big families or bigger groups(think hole in the wall NYC pizza joint) , pizza sometimes burnt, and (frustrating) sometimes understaffed or lack of customer focus that creates long waits to order if in a rush.
MA
Madelyn Rios
Amazing, Excellent just wow... If I could give more than 5 stars, I would. The pizza was very fresh, not greasy and very good. I also ordered the Bruschetta BY FAR THE BEST IVE EVER HAD. All ingredients were so fresh and the flavors were amazing. Stopped here on our way to the beach and would definitely recommend to anyone and everyone...
JA
Jason Hartke
We just moved to Salem, the Sammy the Bull Sandwich is awesome. Tried a few slices of pizza, equally awesome. Its a small take out place with a few tables. The staff there were friendly and they have another full restaurant in Colchester they said. We will have to check that place out too very soon!
JO
Joe Kersch
Got a bunch of pies for a large group. Solid pizza that we all enjoyed. Definitely a good option if youre out in this area. Small storefront; would plan on getting takeout instead of eating at this location.
JO
John Bernard Shaw
I have never had a problem anytime I get pizza here. Its just that it is very thin, very bland pizza. And the slices fall apart as your eating them if that makes sense.
JI
Jim Harings
The pizza is thin and crispy, the salads are HUGE and tasty. Definitely worth the trip.
RU
Russell Young
We love the variety of flavors and styles with excellent ingredients
KI
Kim Hoffmann
The best sandwiches.......had a Tater Tail....yummy!
JE
Jessica Hartke
Best sandwiches ever!! The meatball is my favorite.
DA
David Viera
Best Pizza around for sure, service is great too!
MA
Marco Da Costa
Small place bit the food was delicious
MI
Mike Tebeau
I love the brickini sandwiches here.
AL
Al Aksterowicz
Good place for some good pizza
ZA
Zane Barber
Very good, thin crust style.
SE
Seth Clark
Good quality tasty sandwich
CA
Cameron Lisk
Best pizza place in Ct!
A
A Private User
Pretty good pizza.
MI
Michelle Reiley
Pizza is awesome.
CO
Conrad Mazzei
Good consistency
AL
alphavelo
Great pizza
DE
Dean Palermo
Its alright
