Lake Geneva Pie Co
| Address: | 150 E Geneva Square, Lake Geneva, WI 53147, USA |
| Phone: | +1 262-248-5100 |
| Site: | lgpie.com |
| Rating: | 4.6 |
| Working: | 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–5PM Closed |
Location
Photos 68
Reviews 36
MA
Marlene Machut
Two-crust Cherry Pie: had good taste and tons of cherries but Ive never seen a thicker crust on any pie. My mother pressed the top crust with two thumbs and not even a crack. Despite that it cut with a knife and ended up cutting fairly easily with a fork by the piece. Not sure it is a typical flaky pie crust, more of a hybrid cookie/pie crust -- didnt look appetizing when you saw the thickness. Bottom crust was soggy, to be expected from a fruit pie, although with the crust being so thick, it was even soggier. I would give it a 2.5 -- OK, certainly edible, but not a great pie crust.
GA
GAIL Jachimek
You have got to be joking...a pie for twenty bucks?!?? They are advertising their 15 year anniversary, and I can only wonder who continues to buy $18 pies regularly, in order to to support the company. Seems like a nice place, but the prices dictate a customer base that must really have a pie fetish, or are independently wealthy. God bless them though, that they seem to be successful. I bought one anyhow, for a gift, then went next door and bought a $4 pie for my family at Piggly Wiggly...no worries.
MA
Mary Lesniak
My husband and I stop here once a week for attitude adjustment. We love the "House Quiche" with the artichokes, but there are always three or four types to choose from. Then we treat ourselves to a slice of one of the fresh, home made, pies. The food is wonderful, and the staff is gentle and really pleasant. We are locals and if we were to recommend one stop for a Lake Geneva visitor, it would be this restaurant- for a slice of happiness.
JU
Julie Dwyer
The Pies are so delicious, the crust is just like my Grandma used to make. If you are looking for a Dessert to serve to Family or Friends try these pies. They will be the hit of the party. They are Amazing! The customer service is also a one of a kind. Check this place out!
JO
Jordan Sherfey
Got a roast beef sandwich (cold, you can have it warmed if youd like) on focaccia bread and a piece of lakeshore berry pie. Both were excellent. Will definitely revisit if Im in town again. Service was great and it was very clean inside. Great job!
TR
Troy Semanision
Delicious pies. We tried banana cream pie, coconut cream pie, and peach crumb pie. They were all delicious and the staff were very nice and helpful. We cant wait to try more flavors next time.
WH
Whitey Kaine
Owner has negative attitude . Pies are just okay . They need to hire quality help not school kids . Lots of elderly woman who would love to have s job .Not high school kids who dont care .
CH
Chris S
Was only ok found crust to be so dry and thick but thats my opinion... but what do I know I only had a grandmother who made pies that consistently won first prize at the state fair.
KA
Karen Schinke
We call there weekly and never have had that problem? Best Pies in Wisconsin and Illinois.......also better than any we have found in Florida. I would highly recommend.
MA
Mario Abbatacola
We went there at 4:00pm they close at 6:00 They did not have one slice of pie in the house. Poor planning on the part of the manager.
GR
greg bochniak
Had a great meal there. I recommend the deli sandwiches and soup. The pies are top shelf, I like the cherry and banana cream pies.
MA
Matt Kaminski
Could the web page be any creepier? My god. Great pies though. The banana chocolate creme is to die for.
AN
Anita Stohl
Management is very accommodating, rest of staff - not too much. Food is awesome, but a bit pricey.
MI
MIKE J
A great place to have a quick bite and either a piece or whole pie that you can even take to go
ME
Melissa VanDusen
Great pies! And so many gf choices... you need to order those 2 days in advance.
CO
Cosmo Joe
Nice little cafe style place for pie and quiche. I had the quiche; quite good!
DO
Doreen Davis
Great food, but never try calling ahead because they do not answer their phone
JE
Jennifer Haumschild
Absolutely delicious food, casual place with a warm feel and quality products
TA
tammy johnson
Nothing exceptional but friendly staff, felt it was very dark inside.
YI
yiying Ko
Coffee and muffins are really good with reasonable price!!!
EM
Emily Rabe
Friendly and delicious. Friendly staff, delicious food!
JO
Joshua Ramirez
Loved the pie! A must visit place with great flavor!
A
A Private User
Great Pies! Their Lakeshore Berry Crumb is amazing!
BR
Brian Ware
The pies are outstanding and the owners are so nice
RO
Rob Micklinghoff
Delicious... A bit pricy but worth it for a treat.
JA
Jake Parrillo
Try the lakeshore pie. Apples + Berries FTW.
NI
Nick Melchi
Great pies, great quiche. Would recommend.
FR
Francisco Ramirez
Absolutely delicious food! AMAZING PIES!
JO
Joe Faraci
Phenomenal pies if you are rich
KE
Kevin Sieger
Good quiche, pie, and service!
ED
Edwin Long
Great quiche, love the crust.
RE
rene g. melchor
Nice, for a quick bite.
JO
joanne joanne
Amazingly delicious!
LI
Lisa Conell
Food was great!
FR
Fran Rodgers
Great place ...
AM
Amy Moore
Always great!
