Straight from New York Pizza
| Address: | 2918 Commercial St SE, Salem, OR 97302, USA |
| Phone: | +1 503-361-1234 |
| Site: | sfnypizza.com |
| Rating: | 3.9 |
| Working: | 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–9PM |
Location
Photos 59
Reviews 24
DR
Dr. Keith Neaman
As a New Yorker - I probably have this false sense of authority on Pizza. However, this place is unbelievable. The pizza is awesome and takes me home every time I stop in with the wife and kids. This truly is the best pizza in Salem - hands down. Staff is always friendly and now that they deliver I am going to have to hit the gym more often.
JO
Josh luis
So I called and placed my order, then ten minutes later I get a call back saying the ovens are turned off 45 minutes before close. Im not sure who the owner is, but I certainly wouldnt want to lose customers because my employees are lazy and turn away customers an hour before theyre even closed.
PH
Phil R
The crust was burnt, hardly any cheese, the toppings werent cooked and cold. It was like eating a burnt cracker with leftovers from my refrigerator. I called them afterwards and they offered hardly an apology. Several years ago the pizza was great. The business is suffering.
PA
Paula Connaghan
Took three grand boys to lunch. We all loved the pizza and had a great salad too! It was the lunch time so the pizza was fresh out of the oven. Unfortunately the room was freezing cold and we had to clean our own table. Will try again!
MA
Matt Israel
Had the chicken bacon ranch. SUPER tasty. NOT very hot however. COULD have reheated it a little longer. KINDA spendy. 2 slices of pie and a beer was 11.50. Definitely would do it again despite above concerns.
DA
Danielle Worcester
Came here for lunch and paid almost 8 dollars for salad with warm lettuce and fatty pieces of chicken. They even charged me extra for dressing. Pizza is good but over priced like the salad.
JO
Johnnyboytastic
Walked in on a Sunday the place was dead, dirty with employees standing around. Pizza was not fresh tasting, pizza not that hot and cashier overcharged me. Never going back to this location.
AL
Alex B
Decent pizza by the slice. But often pies have been sitting around a while, so unless you have good timing, the only way to get a really fresh pizza is to order your own.
A
A Private User
Some of the best pizza in salem, I like the thin crust and good flavor. Being able to get slices quickly at lunch is nice too. In and out quickly.
JO
John Belford
Dont listen to the crabby reviews. This place is great and delicious! Best pizza this side of the country! Take it from a new yorker!
MA
Mariah Swayngim
The most amazing pizza EVER... the vegetarian is the bees knees ×s 1,000,000! Also try a slice of the chicken bacon ranch pizza
MI
Mike Honan
Great atmosphere and pizza. You can pick up a growler with a good selection of micro brew beers.
A
A Private User
Great option for quick lunch. Excellent service. Price per slice could be less expensive.
CH
Chris french
Love the pizza and the great customer service!
AL
Alien Mind Trick
Great service, great pizza, great prices.
BR
Brandon Pike
Best pizza by the slice place in Salem.
JI
Jim Thacker
Decent pizza yet, too expensive.
RO
Roland Benoit
Great pizza. A little expensive.
DU
Dustin Johnson
Amazing pizza and great deals
RO
Roger and Bonnie Merulli
one of the best in salem
VI
Victoria Hayes
Yum! Great NY slices!
TJ
TJ Oregon
Good food and service
CH
Charity Porter
Good and expensive
KA
KAT SHEPARD
Great pizza!!
