Fireside Pizza
| Address: | 773 E McMillan St, Cincinnati, OH 45206, USA |
| Phone: | +1 513-751-3473 |
| Site: | firesidepizzawalnuthills.com |
| Rating: | 4.6 |
| Working: | 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 29
SH
Shawn Murphey
Fireside Pizza is the best brick oven pizza Ive had in Cincinnati. It is located in an old firehouse station and there are even murals and pictures on the walls from when it was a functioning firehouse. The pizza is delicious and there are various specialty pizzas as well as a seasonal pizza that is changed every month or so. They have a fairly wide choice of beers including a changing draft list as well as wine and liquor. Its great for kids and it even has 2 arcade machines! The history and feel in the restaurant is amazing. I love the white pie with bacon and jalopenos, and basically all of their seasonal pizzas. Fireside just started Monday trivia night, and occasionally have small bands that play in the evenings - a cool touch. The fact that they can deliver if youre down the street at a bar or close by is awesome. Fun and highly recommended!
WA
WanderingOldSoul
Stopped here on a whim during a random trip to the city! Neighborhood is a bit deceiving, but located in a old Fire Station, this place gives a really homey, authentic feel. The guy who greeted us acted as if he knew us his entire life and we were just coming back to visit! Super personable, super friendly. Had the Margherita Pizza which was fantastic! Super simple, super tasty. I would love to come back again soon! Highly recommend stopping here for a slice or two or three or four! Too good to pass up.
SE
Seth Holt
Great place. I frequently go to Fireside Pizza for lunch and always enjoy it. I love the flavor of the thin crust, wood fire pizza. They also have a good bar, but I havent been able to partake during the day. They also have a parking lot across the street, which is a very nice bonus considering that parking in that neighborhood can be a little tricky for lunch places. Its a great addition to the neighborhood and definitely worth your time.
JE
jeff gilliam
I travel a lot and I always try local pizza places. This was one of the best experiences Ive ever had at a privately owned establishment. As far as food quality and taste it is the best pizza Ive ever had. The cupcakes were delicious as well. I loved the rootbeer, and the atmosphere of the old fire station. If you like restaurants for all of the right reasons and dont mind self sevice this is the perfect place for you.
KE
Kevan Bayne
As you sit back on the sidewalk patio sipping an ice cold draft beer, the smell of delicious pizza and live music fills the air around you. This historic, casual eatery has earned its place among the great spots in Walnut Hills. Any night of the week youll run into friendly authentic people here. Not into pizza or beer? They have excellent salads and wine too!
CH
chris murphy
Pizza was good but the service was awful. The table behind me got the wrong pizza 3 times. The set-up was bad and the guy bringing out the pizza from the kitchen was clueless. Verrrrry slow despite the fact there was 18-19 people in the whole place. Thank goodnees for the pizza its the only keeping this from a 0 out of 5
MA
Mark McEwan
Delicious pizza with a small rotating selection of beers. The historic firehouse atmosphere is casual, comfortable, and fun with a great open garage door to the street when its nice out. My favorite thing is a build your own pizza with pepperoni and sausage or the Redlegger pizza.
JA
Jason Winstel
Pizza was good, but didnt like the red sauce! White sauce was very good n crust was cooked well. Good amount of toppings n rootbeer was very good! Wasnt fond of having to get your own silverware, plates, n utensils, but it is simple! Love that its in an old firehouse !!!!
ST
Steve Ball
I agree with the reviewers who preceded me. Run by great people, very friendly, and has a special ambiance on a rainy summer evening when the garage doors are open and on cold rainy winter evenings in the dim yellow lights. The thin crust cheese pizza is outstanding!
DA
Daniel Castagna
Ive now been to Fireside a dozen times - great wood fired pizza and great atmosphere. Some nice craft beers as well. I had the eggplant parm pizza yesterday and frankly - I decided I needed to offer up this review (It was SOOOOO Good!) The food here is great!
MA
Matthew Brown
Deceptive pricing. The base price is for a naked crust. They charge extra for sauce and cheese. Those are included in the rest of the known universe. They even tried to charge me for a 14" when I ordered a 9". Also, the pepperoni was too greasy.
JE
Jeremiah Griswold
Fireside Pizza is consistently great pizza. They always have good beers on tap and the caesar salad rules. The staff are friendly and awesome, and they are dedicated to their neighborhood. We love this place!
JA
Jamie Jackson
Love the pizza and atmosphere. The only reason I gave a 4 star instead of 5 is due to the confusion of whether or not Im supposed to bus my own table and the service at the table is limited.
YO
Yousef Hussein
Great pizza. Prices add up when adding toppings, but worth it. Fresh ingredients with great flavor. its definitely the better than Pieology, Cucinova, or Blaze pizza. Better ambiance too!
CH
Charles Baker
Im in a bad mood so this review is skewed. Its so loud in that place that I left. All I could hear where the shrilly voices of the the wine-drunk women. Pizza looked like pizza.
TA
Taylor Kantor
Great pizza at a great price. Great atmosphere year round but especially in the warm weather as theyll open up the fireside doors. Definitely a place to experience! Enjoy!
ED
Ed Fowls
Very good pizza, 2 suggestions I would get banner or sign outside would not know open unless knew the area, also maybe add some bread sticks to the menu, but good pizza
TY
Ty Wahlbrink
Surprising neighborhood gem. Great local pizza, decent price, great service. Free parking lot across the street makes it accessible. Dont miss out on this new place!
SC
Scott Hand
Great food. Great vibe. Awesome location. Fireside is my go-to lunchtime meeting spot. Small, but well-curated beer selection, and the pizza is always perfect.
JE
Jeff Stewart
Had great pizza, it was a special hanky panky pizza. Loved having the garage door open on an awesome fall day for lunch. Signage from outside is terrible.
LE
Leland Yoder
Delicious salads, not cheap, but high quality ingredients. I will say that their fountain drinks are a complete and total ripoff. $2.49 for a 12 oz cup?!
IB
IbriYah Yisrael
First place Ive actually been excited about in a while. Its really, really nice in there. They need to advertise. Its like a secret for some reason lol
MA
Matthew Carr
Nice little "hole in the wall" pizza place with a bar to boot. You can watch your pie being made and then cooked in their authentic pizza oven.
D
D Porter
They have great pizza made with healthy, fresh ingredients. The bar has a good selection of local beer, and the service is fast and friendly.
JE
Jeff Napier
Great pizza, great service, we had a group of 30 and they made it seem like we were a small party. Made everything very easy for everyone.
BR
Brianna J
Flys landed on my pizza as I was eating it in the restaurant. Not that great when compared to other pizza options in Cincinnati.
CO
Conard Carroll
Great food, great atmosphere. Had an awesome time with the rents and even saw some people they know. Will go there again.
AN
Antoni Gambetta
Absolutely fantastic experience the food is wonderful the bartender Casey was a lot of fun helpful and very very polite.
KA
Katie Pangallo
The best pizza in the country. No doubt about it. They have the hottest bartenders too!!!! I love fireside forever!!!!
