Cafe Milano Pizzeria & Restaurant
| Address: | 401 Forest Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA |
| Phone: | +1 718-720-1313 |
| Site: | cafemilanosi.com |
| Rating: | 4.1 |
| Working: | 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM |
Location
Photos 83
Reviews 26
SU
Susan D.
There are problems at times with the deliveries. If you oder anything with a thin sauce i have to tell them to put it on the side.otherwise it swims in the box and none in your dinner. Delivery persons dont seem to care. When you call they dont seem to care either. I guess they make so much $$ there they dont care about happy customers. The only food i dont order from them are the personal pies. How does a great pizza joint screw up personal pies? They dont even look appetizing. Tried twiece two different pies. At first i thought it was a joke when I opend the box. Otherwise i love the food the large pies and speciallty pies. I gave up on on line ordering.that always gets screwed up. At this point i know what i can and can not order and how to order the food. Tip: you get a chicken marsala with pasta..make sure you tell them to have the sauce on the side and if you want the marsala sauce on your pasta you need to tell them Otherwise your pasta comes with tomato sauce..like wtf?! I still order there on rare occasion would order a lot more often from there if those problems were fixed incl. The customer service.
WE
Wendy Interlandi
Second time our order was screwed up. First time we requested fresh mushrooms through their online web ordering service and paid extra and we got canned mushrooms. The second time we ordered sauce on the side for the calzone and it didnt come with it. We also ordered two burgers with cheddar that we had to pay $1.00 extra per burger. They called to say they didnt have cheddar but we didnt get our credit back for the more expensive cheese. When we called they told us they couldnt give us our money back but let them know the next time we order that we have a credit. They said he sauce was coming for our calzone but half an hour later when we called to ask where it was they said oh we are sending it now!!! They tried to blame their software for the problems and our solution was to get a new software program. Will not be ordering again from them!!!!!
AN
Anthony CS
This is the second party that I have been to at Cafe Milano, and they never seem to fail to deliver an amazing evening!!! The food is amazing, the price is right, the waitstaff and owner (I think the older gentleman is the owner..?) are all such nice and generous people... and the owner you can tell that he really loves and understands good customer service!!! He literally walks around himself making sure everyones wine glass is full and the food is OK. Amazing place to have a party....I HIGHLY recommend Cafe Milano, and cannot wait to return!
A
A Private User
Cafe Milano consistently serves high quality food at a price affordable even to a poor college student. Their portions are satisfying and very large, almost always leaving food left to take home. The restaurant section is simple and classy, and gives the guest the feeling of being in a more expensive establishment. Their Chicken Francese and generous Linguine with Clam Sauce dishes are to die for. Plus, they deliver!
GI
Gianna Rose
I went on a whim to Cafe Milano. It was February 6th and a good friend and I were famished! So we decided to grab something local. Heard great things about the place (I live right near Primo the other restaurant) It was DELICIOUS!! Every aspect was perfect: service, no waiting on a Saturday night was a score due to this open and spacious layout, and of course the food was exceptional! Going back soon.
BR
Brenda Lavan
Ive only eaten in the restaurant part twice, but was pleasantly surprised since they completed their renovations. Food was good, portions were large, nice atmosphere. If youre just looking for a slice, stop by the pizzeria part. They are very accommodating (my husband has a custom made slice and would go there everyday if I let him). Yum!
PE
Peter John
Pizza is not bad, but we cant figure out why a pizza with no cheese should be more expensive than a regular pizza. We frequently order pizzas from a few different neighborhood places and this is the only place where we pay more for less. (others charge the same and substitute a topping, like onions, for the cheese or charge us less).
M.
M.M. Rivas
Great comfort food! I used to go here after work with my sister-- nice portions, great wine pour, and friendly service. Now I mostly order in, and the delivery is prompt and food good. I usually order traditional pasta dishes and garlic bread. Nice to come home and not have to cook, but feel like you are getting home cooking.
BU
bubbaguitar12
Weve never eaten at the restaurant but the Family dinner take out - 1 pizza pie, order of Penne Vodka, Salad, garlic knots & rolls is good price, about $25 and both parents & kids love it. And the staff inside no matter how busy or frazzled might be always friendly & courteous. Totally recommend whole heartedly...
TR
Traci Cappiello
I enjoy Cafe Milano and have had it many, many times on my trips to Staten Island. They work wonders with a specialty slice (like my friends buffalo chicken and bbq sauce slice) and regular slices alike. I havent been in since the renovation, but it was just a regular old pizza shop, which felt comfortable.
KO
KOMROOK
The food is great.....but the waitresses are not only ugly as sin, but VERY NASTY and condescending to customers. The old hag waitress always talks about how great Obama is.....and was very rude to my 87 year old dad......Never again.
VI
victoria Mavroudis
I order from here all the time while im at work. They are always on time and the drivers are always super friendly. The food its really good and the desserts are amazing! I recommend the mississippi mud pie its the best
MA
Maggie O
Cafe Milano is a nice restaurant with a delicious buffet Monday-Friday for lunch in the restaurant area. The selections are a bit limited, but its still good, though I always recommend the plain cheese pizza.
A
A Private User
Food was passable, but the waitress added an automatic 30 percent tip to our bill, assuming a would pay without checking the bill! Horrible business practice. Im not going back.
AR
Ari gold
Call any pizzaria or diner, ask them what shrimp scampi looks like. Then remind yourselfs of the (7) shrimp I recieved in a container. LOL, say goodbye to business here
LE
lenny castillo
Been going here for years service is great and the food even better!!! Wish the servings were a lil larger considering the prices but still two thumbs way up!!
ME
Melanie Wahl
$20 for delicious gravy covered grilled chicken portabello and smocked mozz. Croquette potato. And haricot verts. Delicious! Would go again.
VI
Vincent Caruso
Top notch restaurant, not just a pizzeria, sauce is phenomenal, calamari is tender and delicious every time! Pizza is dam good too.
WA
walter warren
Good food, decent prices. Pleanty of seating. Great for casual get togethers and smaller formal occasions like graduations birthdays.
LI
Liz Vasquez
Ordered for delivery and the food came pretty fast. The flavors are good and the prices are also good.
JI
Jim McGrath
Great local restaurant. Delicious food and great service. They even offer free delivery.
EL
Elizabeth Cook
Great pizza and baked ziti. Our favorite local pizza shop when we go visit the family.
ST
Steve Segarra
Great food and service exceptional. Huge portions for not alot of money.
JE
Jenni Finch
I tried calling two times for pick up and was hung up on both times.
A
A Private User
Great Pizzeria, fast take-out & delivery service -excellent food!
DA
Daniel Smith
The food is good. I would recommend that people should go there.
