Colandrea Pizza King
| Address: | 362 NY-211, Middletown, NY 10940, USA |
| Phone: | +1 845-343-7275 |
| Site: | ji6433.wixsite.com |
| Rating: | 4.5 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 95
Reviews 32
AL
Alexis Gizzi
I ordered food there by calling in last night. They told me 10 minutes. I got there and it was ready, which is always a good thing. I get online to pay for my food and about 4 people get on line behind me. One of the servers then takes someone from the back of the line behind and about 4 other people and rings them out before the rest of us. Other times I have been there their staff has not been pleasant. I ordered food on the phone once and the woman on the phone was rude, as if I was wasting her time and she couldnt be bothered to take my order. I have ordered food from there several times and have only ever likes their garlic knots. Everything else was nasty. The pizza was rubbery, there was so much O&V on their Italian combo that it completely soaked through the bread, the baked ziti was very oil-y, and their "leave-it-to-us" sub has flavors on it that do not blend well together.
MA
Ma Fred
I used to live in M-Town, but left many years ago. I used to get Colandreas Sicilian and it was delicious. Everyone got their pies from there. I was surfing the net, reminiscing and stumbled across Colandrea. So many places I remembered have closed and so many things have changed in M-Town. Havent been back in almost 2 decades. Colandrea has stood the test of time with everything closing around them, they remain. I was shocked, but not surprised; they were that good. Thats enough proof for anyone who hasnt tried their pies to know they will not be disappointed. One thing - the prices went way up, but I guess its been a while since I saw a menu; I am still on the 1985 teenagers pricing schedule! lol Must make a trip up to M-Town soon and visit a place I enjoyed so much as a teenager. Thanks for some very special memories Colandrea Pizza King!
K
K Simone
Called ahead for a cheese pie to pick up. I was told my order was going to be number seven. I arrived no more than 10 minutes after the call and asked for number seven at the counter, to which the counter help took one of the pizza boxes from the top of the oven and pulled the order slip off and tossed it in the garbage. I was skeptical about the pizza being done in less than 15 minutes but left with the pizza anyway. When I got home in 10 minutes I was treated with a luke warm pizza that the crust was like leather. Obviously I was handed a pizza that someone else ordered well before me and didnt pick up. Never again.
BR
Brian Ludwig
Terrible service. Ordered a pizza there last week and it was good. I then called back to order the exact same pizza this week and was told they "dont make that here." It was not awfully complicated (vodka sauce and fresh mozzarella). The gentleman answering the phone was incredibly rude. Will never go here again.
A
A Private User
I work in Middletown and get their food at least twice a week. They have the best pizza in a 50 mile radius in my opinion. The shrimp parm sub is absolutely amazing as well as the cheese steaks and sausage and pepper subs! I have never been dissapointed by them. Just wish they delivered!
AS
Ashley Martin
This is the only business that survived the shopping mall shut down and when you eat here youll know why! The pizza is by far the best in town and the servers are super friendly. The only downside is they dont deliver but i dont think theyd be able to handle the demand if they did.
RI
Rian Floco
Great bite..... made to order with attention to detail / non peak hours is best. Go in with a soup Nazi attitude & IT gets done..... ppl pussyfooting the menu, squash the experience. »»» make it 5star ? Need 5 sports minded tvs that play 5 different events.
JE
Jessica Hetlyn
Poor customer service and false advertising. I used to love the food and enjoyed going in. With all the fast chain pizza places in the area service like this can ruin an overpriced business. We took our business elsewhere and I have no desire to return.
JO
Joel Santiago
Name says it all! Pizza is outstanding, cheese steaks are amazing. Dinner options from the menu are delicious and huge portions. Old school pizza shop feel, could use an update. The staff is eager, friendly and accomodating.
JO
Joseph Labianca
Love Colandreas pizza. First went here when I was living in middle town when I was young. I make sure to stop here Everytime I visit. Excellent food and service, and one of my all time favorite pizza shops of all time.
PE
Peter Hewel
This is easily the best pizza in Middletown and we have some OK pizza in Middletown. Ive had pizza all over Orange and Rockland county as I work in a service industry and this is in the top 3 of the region for me.
A
A Private User
Best pizza EVER!!! My hometown..and still my fav...everytime I go home,Colandreas is my 1st stop!! Never lets me down!Owners are awesome people!!! A true landmark,Middletown just wouldnt be the same without them!
NI
Nicole Roca
I love this place! They make the best pizza in the Hudson Valley. I also love their calzones and chicken parm sandwiches. The waitresses are always very friendly and attentive. Great place!
BR
Brian Fediuk
Their food is absolutely delicious. We often go here to get a jumbo calzone. Be warned, it is A LOT of food! Great for lunch, dinner, late night snacks, or just because you want pizza.
SA
Sarah Frey
Best NY pizzeria in the area. No matter what you order the food is excellent. Canzones are made fresh to order, best marinara sauce in town, as well as best cheese steak in town!
C
c candito
My family has been coming to this place since it opened. We live in Arizona now but its always our first stop when we come back to visit every year. Pizza and subs are THE BEST!
MA
Marlene Fabregas
The best pizza, Ive found in Middletown. The manicotti are to die for. The last time I ordered a meatball sub and absolutely was as I expected.. delishes. Great good.
AD
Adrian Tymczyszyn
I have been coming here since they opened in 1980. Never dissapointed (Well, almost never. Nobodys perfect). My FAVORITE pizza place!
LE
Leslie Mizerak
A wonderful calzone! The food is delish and the server is delightful! My first time here thanks to a Google search!
A
A Private User
So good youll be in heaven. Its never changed and I hope it never does except the staff their a little mean
NO
Norman Wilson
The pizza is the best that Ive had.....Ive been getting pizza there since I was a kid in the early 90s
DA
David Burlingame
Possibly the best pizza in the Middletown and surrounding area. Decent pricing and friendly service.
LE
Lehi Miranda
Best pizza in Middletown hands down! They dont deliver because they dont need to. Its worth the trip!
RE
RevDominick Reyes
great pizza. a bit expensive compared to all new joints opening these days. but still very decent.
MI
Michael Quinn
The place you take people to demonstrate what real New York pizza is supposed to taste like.
TA
Tanya Witt
The pizza here is so yummy!!! Ive been eating here for years and its always so good!!!
JO
Johnny Cetta
100%! Awesome food and awesome business! From Middletown and this is where I eat!
GR
Greg Yetter
Everything is terrific. You can tell that they use only the finest ingredients.
BR
Brenda Jenkins
Always the best !! Left town for several years came back and still the best !!!!
SH
Shaan Sarode
Great pizza freshly made and lots of great toppings and flavors to come back for
BE
Beavis Butthead
Best pizza in Middletown. Get the large extra cheese and pepperoni well done.
JE
Jessie Ramírez de Tapia
This place has been around since the 80s. Excellent Italian-American cuisine!
