New York Burger Bar
| Address: | 4225 Merrick Rd, Massapequa, NY 11758, USA |
| Phone: | +1 516-799-9199 |
| Site: | nyburgerbar.com |
| Rating: | 4.2 |
| Working: | 11:30AM–11PM 11:30AM–11PM 11:30AM–11PM 11:30AM–11PM 11:30AM–11PM 11:30AM–11PM 12–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 21
GE
Gene Ballesty
I came to nybb with high expectations especially with their proclaimed #1 burger by Newsday. Starting this off by saying that the hostess and bar staff were absolutely delightful, and worked with us and our awkward party situation, but that was the only positive part of my experience. The parking is nonexistent. We parked in the lot directly behind the building, where one of the entrances is located. Apparently we ran the risk of being towed, and I had to park a few blocks away on the side street. Portion sizes were very small, especially for +$8 appetizers. For $16 I ordered supposedly the best burger on Long Island, medium rare, and was served a bland hockey puck with napalm cheese inside. Hungry, and without the time to wait for another, I ate the burger. The fries I feel were so greasey that I can only assume the potato was there to garnish the oil. There are many delicious, inexpensive, consistent, and down right sinful options for burger joints in Massapequa. Sadly, I do not feel that New York Burger Bar can be counted amongst them. The happy hour deals are the only thing that I enjoyed, and felt were worth the trip. Edit: luckily, my experience above was the only bad experience I have had since going to nybb. It seems my first visit must have been a fluke. I think they are a bit more on the pricy side of things
YU
yun X
We returned here for the second time since the reopening and we are SO happy this restaurant is back!!!! Tonight we were a party of 7 and everyones food was amazing... Our waiter Joe was TERRIFIC!!!! He was super attentive, pleasant, accommodating, and overall genuine... Even if the food was just ok, our experience with our waiter would have prompted is to return just based on the service... Our food was awesome as usual and the drinks were made correctly (according to my husband).... I cant say enough good things about this restaurant... Being a local and dining out often, I cant honestly say that this is the best burger restaurant in town!! My review has been updated from previous ones and after visiting here often, I only had one off night where our service wasnt that great, but everyone can have an bad night... And that review was still 4 stars... Love love love NY Burger Bar!
CH
chris licausi
We have eaten here over a dozen times and yes sometimes is busy and for a buisness owner that is a good thing, sorry Cameron theres a wait and you were looking for free food or drink but at my restaurant I wouldnt have gave you nothing either. Apparently your what we like to call a pain in the ass customer. But the burgers are great here much better then George Martins up a few blocks and everyone is very nice..congrats on your success and thank you for making my crazy burger with everything on it,NO BUN you guys are awesome
DO
Domonique Medina
Attended here with a friend. The time is clearly listed as closing at 11 online. We arrived at 9:50 after driving 45 minutes to get there. When we walked in the manager said the kitchen was closed since they were slow, he decided to close early. He did not show an remorse so We went to tai show down the road for sushi. No matter how slow they are they always stay open to the time listed!! Wont be back to burger bar
CA
Cameron Nicholson
We waited literally an hour for just burgers and fries. It wasnt even a busy evening. The manager said they were backed up because an order got messed up. It doesnt take an hour to make burgers and fries. He didnt even offer to pay for anything or take the drinks off of our checks. I do not recommend and I would never go back. The burgers didnt even taste good enough to wait more than 10 minutes.
GE
Geff Gruber
Waitress sucked. Food was not worth the money. We asked for water and waited 15 mins for it. And while we were waiting for our waters and drinks the Waitress was gossiping with other wait staff. She rarely came to our table she was more focused on the other tables.And when asked for more drinks she ignored us. Also my friend got sick from the boneless wings. Wont be going back
TA
Taylor Labrador
I totally understand that things get busy and mistakes happen, but this is some of the worst service I have ever had. It wasnt even busy. The food took way too long to come out and the orders were messed up. I dont know what it was I ate, but I was so sick from it the day after that I literally thought I was going to die.
MI
Miguel Torres
While set in a casual bar, the burger is anything but casual. This is a premium burger spot. Their proprietary blend of meat sets it apart from the rest. My favorite is The Juicy Lucy. If you dont like any choices on the menu, you can custom make your own burger. My kids love the shakes. Great craft beer selection.
AN
Anthony Scotto
Great Service and craft Burgers and Beers. Comfortable setting with able staff but bring your appetite. My burger was topped with braised short ribs, my daughter had fried Mac-n-cheese atop hers. A pair of milk shakes round out the menu which are a meal in themselves. Share, Share, Share.
CH
Chris Feniello
Great burger. Fresh. I ordered medium rare and it actually was medium rare. The fries were homemade and hot. You can build your own burger with all the right toppings. Staff was friendly and attentive. I would definitely go back. Check them out.
RI
Rich H
This place is great with one minor problem, the bathrooms are not the most well kept. The food is great, I recommend the Brooklyn Cyclone burger or the North Shore burger. The service and atomosphere is wonderful! Overall a good experience.
DA
DAVID NO LAST
Took the Drive from Queens all the way out to Massapequa to New York Burger Bar for great burgers and fun times . The place is high energy and has Great Amazing Burgers . Love the Marshmallow sauce for dipping French Fries In !
RI
Rich DiLallo
The food and service here were absolutely incredible. The menu is nothing short of extraordinary. I cant say enough good things about Burger Bar! Youre really missing out if you havent made your way here yet!
AL
Allie Kolitsa
The food was well cooked and delicious. Also the environment was laid back, although the chairs were a little uncomfortable. The bar tender Paul was very friendly and genuine. The waitress was very friendly.
SC
Scott Siegel
place is awesome! staff n mgmt r the nicest! came in w my 19mo old son n we had a great experience!! will definately b back again real soon!
RI
Richard Greer
This place is amazing! I absolutely loved the burgers on the menu, as well as the excellent beer selection. Would definitely recommend.
JA
Jason Lazarus
Burgers good but I felt they were a bit pricey. Lack of parking stinks too. I wont go out of my way to go there. Atmosphere was nice.
S
S O
Great selection of beers on tap, and a great atmosphere. Parking is a little confusing so make sure you ask the staff where to park.
DI
Di Ana
Theyre back! Get the juicy Lucy! Their milkshakes are as decadent as black tap. If youre feeling extra hungry get the pretzel too.
JO
Joshua Scheid
Good food, but was a terribly long wait after placing our order. I thought it was pricey for what we got. Love the atmosphere.
ZA
Zachary Neal
Great selection and variety of burgers and the taste is amazing. My pick over the GM Burger Bar thats down the block.
