The Pie Store
| Address: | 100 Watchung Ave, Montclair, NJ 07043, USA |
| Phone: | +1 973-744-4424 |
| Site: | thepiestorenj.com |
| Rating: | 4.7 |
| Working: | 10AM–7PM 10AM–7PM 10AM–7PM 10AM–7PM 10AM–7PM 10AM–6PM 11AM–5PM |
Location
Photos 44
Reviews 30
JA
Jackie Nolot
If youre a vegetarian and looking for a savory pasty/pie, dont come here. We visited this locale looking for a yummy pasty since moving from Phoenix where there was delicious and vegetarian-friendly pasty shop. Its not advertised anywhere, but after asking the staff, they said that their crusts are made with lard. Its unfortunate that they cant switch to all butter like the other shop we visited, or at the very least advertise that the savory pies are not vegetarian.
ST
stephanie Quintana
I have been deprived my whole life of excellent meat pies. Until this afternoon when I went to The Pie Store, it changed my perspective of what a meat pie could be. Excellent food great helpful service. The only downside is that parking is difficult.
CO
Colin McCarthy
As an Englishman I can tell you these are the best pies on the planet and Im sure the Queen would back me up on that (assuming she came to Montclair and tried them. Even Prince Charles who owns his own line of Cornish pasties would love them too)
RE
Red and White SC Kearny
$$$ priced more than you would expect. The quality of baked goods are good, selection could be better. Come to find out Trad Scottish meat pies not made on premises and were expensive. Trad sausage rolls good, but also overpriced.
AN
Ann Hardy
Some of the best food in this area! Fantastic pasties, and all kinds of pies. Hearty Steak & Mushroom and delicious hand-held Soccer pies are favorite savouries, Key Lime is the best Ive ever had! Not to be missed!
LA
Lara Cely
Dont look at the prices, just treat yourself! I cant stay away - all my favorites are here... McVities caramel digestives, Heinz salad cream, HP sauce... and the handmade pies are outstanding.
JE
Jenette Lindahl
The food is Phenomenal! The staff is friendly and knowledgeable. The store is immaculately clean. I can not say one bad word about this store! If you havent been you are missing out!
M
M Magnus
What a great and unique place. The key lime pie is the best Ive tasted and you can pick up European candies, sodas and pantry items. Dont forget the poppers at holiday time
AM
Amanda Caringi
From the freshly baked strawberry scones to the amazing key lime pie, hands down the best bakery Ive been to. My family devoured the pie and asked for more.
EL
Elizabeth Reed
Portuguese custard tarts were perfection! Masala pasty was absolutely wonderful and the pastry held together but was delicate tasting, not at all tough.
ER
Eric Canepa
They always make amazing pies here. Everything is fresh and you can tell its made from scratch. The employees are very nice as well and very helpful.
HO
Honey Bee
All I can say is WOW! Their key lime pie is the best I have ever had. All of their pies are so fresh and delish. Greatly recommend!!!
RE
Rebecca Goguen
Wonderful savory and sweet pies. They sell all kinds of British food and goodies here like Cadbury and crisps. Scones are delish.
JO
Jon Loruenser
I must place for any anglophile. They even have twiglets. And their combinations for there pasties are quite interesting.
JO
Jordan Lynch
Super friendly staff and a nice selection of English treats. I shall return.
DE
Declan Carney
Best shepherds pie this side of the pond and fantastic, friendly staff
JM
JM Alexandre
Very unique and old world feel. Pies are pricy but phenomenal.
JO
Joe Donato
Dont waste your time at holidays the store has not available.
A
A Private User
Fantastic! and pick up some Hobnobs while you are there...
ZE
Zenon Markewycz
Old world London feel. Authentic recipes. Perfection.
HE
HECTOR & LEE PIZA
Delicious food. Great place great staff!
JA
Javier Alvia
Lots of goodies from the UK and good pies
SU
suhaib ashraf
Key lime pie ! Thats all i am saying
A
A Private User
Those pies are Delicious!!!
CH
Christian Atexide
Best key lime pie ever!
JO
Joshua Crandall
Great and FRESH.
MA
Mark Yun
i like these pie
KA
Kai Jensen
Great pot pies.
BA
Barbara Sandberg
Love their pies
ST
Steven Hahn
Best pie
