Scoop Shack

Address:	22 Dock St, Edgartown, MA 02539, USA
Phone:	+1 508-627-7829
Rating:	3.7
Working:	10AM–11PM 10AM–11PM 10AM–11PM 10AM–11PM 10AM–11PM 10AM–11PM 10AM–11PM

Location

Photos 39

Reviews 7

Sarah Jasmine

excited to come to this eatery after reports of great lobster rolls at a price of only 7 bucks but i was immediately let down after finding they had raised the price to a horrifying 19.50 dollars! it is very shocking this business thought it could price such a dish at such a shocking price. i did try the lobster roll after hearing such brilliant stories about it and seeing the Islands #1 rated plastered on the chalkboard. It was a huge letdown. The bun was limp, tasteless and unsatifactory at holding the lobster salad. the size of the lobster roll was also limited- i was exspecting something that would FILL ME UP at such a steep price but i was left hungry and deeply unsatisfied. A discarded gherkin was awkwardly placed next to a small serving of overly salty fries and I felt frustrated i had spent so much money on something which was made with little care and love. I warn all visitors to Edgartown to keep away from this eatery and not be fooled by its reputation and advertisements! If you are hungary and after something to eat i would recommend walking 5 steps further to A slice of Edgartown which serves a large tasty slice of pizza at the price of 3.50 dollars. The card machine was not working which was incompetent and inept and I regret this The price here is disrespectful and frustrating and would advise many to not invest in such a limited dish.

Jago Henderson

The prices at the scoop shack are extortionate! For one lobster roll it costs 19.50 plus tax!!!! So disrespectful to the customer! I did end up buying the dish as a treat for myself and it is such a let down! The bun is nasty, has no flavour and doesnt hold the lobster salad well. The chips are salty and unpleasant. I left the scoop shack hungry (the portion size is very small) and angry at wasting 20 dollars which I could of spent on some decent food!!

Colin Wuerthele

Best Ice Cream in town by far. These two 1-star reviews are really funny because 1 - they are complaining about a totally different venue as it is an ice cream shop, not a lobster roll store. 2 - that is a very reasonable price for a lobster roll.

Matthew Nesser

Been going for years as its the best but recently got 4 pints of which 2 were totally freezer burnt. For $6.50 / pint I expect more

Kerry Gallivan

Hands down the best ice cream on the island. Super friendly staff and a wonderful candy section while you order.

Adam Vítek

Really nice place with various choices of ice cream and unique flavors.

Aman Patel

Best ice cream ever