Nicola Pizza
| Address: | 8 N 1st St, Rehoboth Beach, DE 19971, USA |
| Phone: | +1 302-227-6211 |
| Site: | nicolapizza.com |
| Rating: | 4.2 |
| Working: | 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM 11AM–12AM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 13
JD
Jd P
Nicola Pizza...not the best but tasty.Went there as a family..2nd time around. First was in their original location this time in the new location on the avenue. Hostess and Wait staff friendly enough.The only beef(pardon the pun) is that one orders as family and receive bits and pieces as the order comes in. Our table was lucky...our kids got the food first...I was the last one to receive the food...my kids had almost finished. Restaurant 101 dictates that the order should all come out at the same time...not here..If that is okay with you...I say enjoy the pizza and Nico-Boli...The table behind us got the adults order in first and the small child was waiting for his kids meal...has one reviewer indicated in an earlier review "there must be a better way to do things"....no need for a third visit from our family who loves Rehoboth Beach and its nice to see not all restaurants here work this way...some great food here in Rehoboth.
A
A Private User
Simply the worst- Nationwide! Visited Rehoboth for the Dogfish Head Brewery and stopped in the restaurant for a much needed respite of za. Order two pizzas with spinach, mushroom, sausage, and peppers. When ordering, I asked for green peppers, the waitress (remarkably apathetic) let me know they didnt have green peppers. Im not culinary expert, but it seems to me that green peppers are just kind of a pizza staple. She let me know they had sweet peppers and would put those on the pizza. The mushrooms and spinach were obviously from a can. When picking the pizza up from the tray, they cheese and toppings were baked in such a way that everything on the pizza would just kind of naturally avalanche off. The sweet peppers were incredibly out of place on pizza and Im sure would taste bad on their own merit. Anyways: exorbitant and just bad. Caution.
BI
Bill McCurdy
Loved the restaurant! We had a table of 7 with 3 kids and was seated within 15 mins on a busy weekend night. Service was outstanding. Our waitress was super busy but still took the time to makes sure we had everything we needed at all times. The owner even stopped by to make everything was alright. Loved it, its a very well run restaurant. But the pizza was terrible. We order two cheese pizzas, they came out hot and fast but I hated the taste. The crust is like a rock, my wife bent her fork trying to cut a piece in half yikes and the sause just tasted bad to me. I can see why it is popular and would probably go back just because they treated us so well, but I wouldnt eat the pizza.
BR
Brian Farber
The NicOBoli was really good, the waitress was awesome, BUT the cook dropped my wifes NicOBoli on the floor pulling it out of the oven. The manager came over and told us, she apologized offered something to hold my wife over till her new Boli was ready. Which was nice of her, then on top of that they gave her meal for FREE nobody does this anymore. Things happen and they took care of it. Very impressive. We will be back again . The sports Bar upstairs is very nice Flat screens everywhere. Nice atmosphere. Have to catch a Skins game there someday.
NI
Nick D
Worst pizza I have had in some time, the reviews I read before going must be a bit biased. Stopped in yesterday second time in my life. The first time was not that memorable and I figured I give them a second chance. to make it short the pizza contents dough, sauce and cheese is all canned made. Absolutely no taste or flavor very blan. Save your money and buy a digiornos you will not be disappointed. The pasta also terrible no taste, the sauce is canned sauce the meatballs looked like low quality frozen from Costco. Will never go back!!!
MA
Martha Lofton
it is not my experience it is this couple that was turned away because of their baby. your place should be ashamed of treating them that way. you wouldnt dare turn a person in a wheel chair away . oh maybe you would . if you turned away a tiny baby in a stroller. You know that was wrong and need to apologize to this couple on Facebook . because it has gone viral how they were treated. God have mercy on you and your workers for turning this couple with this poor sick baby away from your pizza business.
MA
Matt Kus
Still the best pizza at the beach (light years better than the huge chain that starts with "G") with a good selection of other extremely filling comfort food. The Nic-o-bolis are always filling and always come piping hot, stuffed with delicious cheese and other ingredients. The fries are very good, on par with Thrashers, way better than Boardwalk Fries, but not as consistently delicious as DBs. The pasta is good for kids or people who consider pizza to be too "exotic". Very friendly staff.
DA
Damon Jay
I went in 3 or 4 days ago around 8 and a girl Michelle with tattoos everywhere was complaining she made no tips and cursing throwing a fit , saying this was b.s. she didnt come back to this it was very uncomfortable, I love the pizza but my family and I will not be returning ,her mother should wash her mouth out with soap ,my god those tattoos prob a my scare off the older.customers terrible experience! I hope she doesnt get fired but maybe she needs a different profession
EM
Emily Forde
This was hands down the best pizza I have EVER had! I think I could say 1,000 things about the gracious waiters and hosts, family atmosphere, and beyond reasonable prices but in the end it all comes down to taste. Everything I had was fresh and extremely flavorful. Nicola Pizza I hope you around for many years to come. I cant wait to come back again. And yes, I would travel all the way from DC to Delaware just for Nicolas. After you taste it you will understand why. :)
GR
Gregory Pettine
Been a regular for 35 years. "Everything with fish and extra sweet peppers and a side of sauce" is my suggestion if you like that kinda thing. Its all i have ever ordered in 35 years, you can check the record. Sure i have tried most items on the menu as we always have extras. Split a bucket of salad and fries if you go with a few families. Cheese sticks, chix fingers and pizza still a kids favorite. Go and go early unless you like to wait. It is worth it.
WI
William Meekins
We go here often as a family. Prices are pretty cheap esp for being at the beach. Baked ziti is amazing. Never had to wait for a table and service usually on point. Only reason Im not putting 5 stars is because every time we order a frozen drink it comes out almost half way melted, every single time. Besides that, its a good place for the whole family. They also do military discounts. Marc, who used to work there, was a great bartender.
MI
Michael Rosenberg
I cannot rave enough about this place. The pizza is GREAT (and this is coming from a New Yorker!). The ground beef "Nicoboli" was also very good. The wait to get a table during prime time over the summer wound up being only 5 minutes, even though they tone us 25 minutes. The waitress was also excellent. We drove up from Ocean City to return to this place after having gone years before and we would definitely return again!
A
A Private User
The atmosphere in here is pretty crazy. Theres a loudspeaker where somebody watches the door and then announces the table number over a loudspeaker (so a server comes to the table). It seems like there has to be a better way of doing things. It became really annoying listening to that every time someone entered. The Nicola bowl was good. Ask for a side of extra sauce. It comes free and goes a long way.
