Address: | 275 Bayville Ave, Bayville, NY 11709, USA |
Phone: | +1 516-628-2000 |
Site: | millcreekny.com |
Rating: | 4.5 |
Working: | Closed 4:30–9PM 4:30–9PM 4:30–9PM 4:30–10PM 4:30–10PM 4:30–9PM |
LA
Laura Cienkowski
The food and the environment at Mill Creek are both incredible! The staff is always super friendly and Rich, the owner, is often there greeting people, checking on tables and really giving it the amazing local restaurant feel. My husband and I also hired Rich and his team to cater our off premises wedding and we would recommend them to anyone and everyone without hesitation!! Not only was the food amazinggg, from the hor dourves to the dessert (none of our guests could stop talking about it) but Rich and his team went above and beyond to make sure everything was perfect. He worked with us for 6 months leading up to the event and was at the outdoor venue almost every day the week prior to the event making sure that all of the rentals were taken care of and that we had a backup plan if it rained. He even came up with an amazing idea for late night snacks that included hot dogs, soft pretzels, churros, and italian ices for our guests as they were leaving. People were blown away (us included). He also sent out mini root beer floats to people on the dance floor and provided special (and delicious) gluten free meals for a couple of our guests with celiacs disease! I could go on and on. The point is, go to Mill Creek for a meal and if youre having a party - hire them!! You wont regret it :)
MA
Madelaine Houston
Mill Creek is one of the many reasons to never leave Bayville: its a wonderful place for a family meal, romantic for an evening out without the kids, fantastic food, fabulous service (love to Meghan, Vanessa and Rich) and an all around awesome staff that does everything possible to make your visit outstanding. Mill Creek has been a part of my familys life for the past ten years -- from our first date, to our first family dinner, baptisms, parties and quick dinners out when no one has the energy to cook. We love Mill Creek - thank you for being a part of my familys life and for helping make Bayville an incredible community!
MA
Mark Minsky
We havent been to Bayville in quite awhile. Yet, we forgot how much fun it can be. Mill Creek Tavern certainly contributed to that feeling last night. MCT is a really cute place with an extensive menu of well executed food. The blackened salmon and sauteed chicken were delicious and we cant wait to come back and order again. The portions are generous and well worth the price. Our server, Vanessa, was an asset as she helped us navigate the menu. Check out this place if you want a great meal in a fun, beachy, north shore environment.
A
A Private User
By Tami - April 18, 2010 I am a diner who has no problem paying good money for a great meal. I want quality and creativity and I will pay for it. My ceasar salad tasted flat...not a hint of anchovy, not a twinge of garlic, and absolutely no acid and the person who put it on the plate must have been having a bad day and this was before they got busy. The scallops with lobster risotto was a discrace!!!! The lobster tasted old and the rosotto was dry...not loose and creamy and the scallops were over-cooked and all of it was luke warm.
BR
Bruce Reed
I recently had the opportunity to eat at this restaurant. I started with the iceberg wedge, with warm bacon and blue cheese dressing - just the right amount of crunchy bacon! Im a big fan of short ribs, so next I had the Braised Short Ribs, which were nice and tender, served with an innovative approach to potatoes - horseradish whipped potatoes. The horseradish seemed to intensify the creaminess of the potatoes. This quaint spot nestled on the North Shore is a perfect detour on my way home.
WI
William Lapadula
My experience at this fine establishment was one I shall never forget. Upon entering the so-called tavern, I was blasted away with a feel of fine restaurant mixed with a young ambiance. This is no tavern. The music choice is a fiery mix of EDM which makes me wonder how many people in here are rolling. The food was very good so far as I have not got my entree yet and have only had my appetizer. My overall experience was quite swell and will enjoy coming back in more appropriate raving attire.
MI
michael bednar
Great Happy Hour Great Food!! A few of us stopped in last week to Mill Creek. A cozy little restaurant in Bayville. Kathy was the bartender. extremely personable as well as funny and very attentive. We had several apps tuna tartare, Chicken wings Chili Pop Shrimp, and Calamari all very good especially the Calamari. The atmosphere is great with a fireplace that gives a terrific ambiance to both the bar and dining room. I cant wait to give the dining room a try!!
SA
Sara Habib
Awesome Spot On The Water: We went for a family members birthday and had a great time. The staff was very polite and accommodating. The food was delicious and there was something on the menu for everyone at our table. The service was fast and the manager came around to see how the food came out. The staff was also very nice and came out with candles in the dessert. This place is awesome and I recommend it to everyone!
CH
Christopher Kortmann
Great food, great service. Enjoyed a drink at the bar before being seated for dinner. Bartender was helpful with a recommendation on a beer. I had the buffalo chicken spring rolls for an appetizer and the meatloaf as an entree. I was very happy with both! Unfortunately I was too full for dessert, but I saw a table that had the smores and I cant wait to return and try them!
BR
Brian Cooper
Excellent food. 6 of us, and ask enjoyed our dishes. Helpful, patient wait staff. They did actually make some mistakes with some of our complicated "custom" meal requests, but they handled it graciously. Nice ambience in back room where we sat. Highly recommend.
DE
Debbie Barbieri
Had a great dinner with my friends last night. We enjoyed sharing the mussel and the spinach artichoke dip. Entrees were also excellent we had the linguine seafood, mac and cheese and linguine white clam sauce. Service was great. We will be back.
AM
Amanda Hassel
Love everything about this place. the nice quiet booths and fireplace in the main dining room. The friendly servers and excellent food. The back room is great for parties and the bar has live music every Friday night. Definitely worth the trip
GE
Geraldine Basile
I went there with a few friends last week for the first time. Staff was very friendly and welcoming. Love love the food! The mussels were out of this world! Its very hard to find a good place that makes them, but they certainly past the test.
JE
Jennifer Purpi
Love this restaurant one if our go to favorites. Regular menu is large enough that you can always try something and specials are usually great. Never have had a bad meal. Cant beat the beer selection as well as always impeccable service.
JA
James Karalis
Love this restaurant. Such a cute cozy, and quaint place. Menu has a wide variety for people to choose from. Service is always attentive, efficient and friendly. Must try the Jager Schnitzel on the Oktoberfest menu!
DE
Dennis Gross
i have been going to Mill Creek for almost three years at least once a week, it like coming home to family when i go there. they know who i am and of course what i like. Food is great and service is suburb.
VA
Vanessa Koch
The place gets better with age. Love the new menu. Pretzel Baked Brie, fantastic, Escargot à la Provence OMG. The service is always excellent and friendly. We keep coming back. Keep up the good work.