Good Fellas Tavern

Address:	109 S State St, Argyle, WI 53504, USA
Phone:	+1 608-543-3606
Rating:	4.9
Working:	10:30AM–2AM 10:30AM–2AM 10:30AM–2AM 10:30AM–2AM 10:30AM–2:30AM 10:30AM–2:30AM 8:30AM–2AM

Location

Photos 81

Reviews 28

Wayne Lin

Apparently Good Fellas is the place to be on a Sunday night. There was a good crowd around dinner time, but still plenty of space for our party of 6 to sit and get some drinks and food. Our group was definitely the out of town visitors here, but we loved the small town bar atmosphere. People of all ages were present from early 20s to folks in the 60s-70s and they would say hi to each other as they came and went. Food is typical bar food, but done well. The deep fried cheese curds, deep fried string beans, burgers, prime rib sandwich, and BLT are all very good. Our waitress/bartender was friendly and she came by frequently to check up on us. Prices are great too! (Compared to city prices in NYC and Washington DC that were used to paying.)

Michael Moen

This is one of best bars in SW WI. They have it all! Great burgers, like their pepper jack burger and specials with their fried veggies Plus they make my favorite drink, the Moscow Mule. Jason definitely knows how people tick and he will let you know it! It is fun plus they have people from all over the country. You will love the party atmosphere on the weekends. All in all, this is the place to be!!

Todd Hardin

Never had a reason to go to Argyle before, but after eating at Good Fellas during a basketball tournament, Argyle has become a destination. We left full, happy, and impressed. Outstanding burgers, pizza, apps, and more. Top notch and personal service even through the rush. All this and I didnt need to take out a second mortgage. Well done, Good Fellas. Well be back!

Anna Marie Torre Wright

What an awesome neighborhood bar! One of the best burgers Ive had. The fried string-beans and half-nekkid curds are to die for. Seriously, their food is so yummy, we ate there twice when we were only in town for a few days. Friendly folks, great food!

Jason Dammen

Thank you very much for all of your reviews. We here at Good Fellas Tavern appreciate any and all feedback possible to help make a better customer experience. We hope to have the opportunity to serve you all again very soon!

Heather Phillipson

I went to Goodfellas for the first time tonight & i really loved it! The food was great, people were really friendly, and it is very laid back. I had a good time! :-)

Jim Jacoby

Food is OK. Cash only, ATM in the bar. Dont have much to say about beer/cocktail selection, as Ive only ever eaten here with the kiddos.

Janette Boyer

Awesome place with pool table. The Moscow Mule was the best in the copper cup! The best curds in town!

Jeff Daily

Out of this world burger and make sure to get the pepper jack cheese curds!

Hans Vraga

I dare anyone to find better food and service for the price.

Cat Duran

Excellent food for reasonable prices. Friendly staff.

Ron Bredeson

The best food drinks and service in Wisconsin