P & J Pizza
| Address: | 22 E High St # 1, Elizabethtown, PA 17022, USA |
| Phone: | +1 717-367-9681 |
| Rating: | 3.5 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 12–10PM |
Location
Photos 17
Reviews 42
JO
John M
After reading over Googles recommendations for restaurants nearby I settled on P & J Pizza. The parkings in a little one way side lot, so when you exit youre going to be taking a back road to get out; beware in the dark if youre unfamiliar with the area, as I was. The guy working the counter was also preparing pizzas so he was understandably busy, though he was still patient and answered my questions as I took my time looking over the menu. I ordered the mild buffalo boneless wings and the loaded fries, both of which were hot and fresh even by the time I made it home. I was thoroughly impressed with the fancy aluminum container the fries were in, as it kept them warmer than any styrofoam container wouldve. The wings were fine, I mean, theyre boneless wings at a small pizza restaurant- theyre not exactly crafted from the finest meat, but by all means I enjoyed eating them. The same goes for the loaded fries as well, it was great that they managed to make it all the way home without getting soggy from the cheese. All in all, it was a good choice for a late night dinner.
AN
Andrew Rhoads
Best tasting pizza in Elizabethtown. Best dough, generous portions and great Italian Hoagies. If you want pizza that tastes like cardboard or cheap ingredients, go elsewhere. I understand how people might think theyre rude but I personally can excuse that because I know what its like working around hot ovens and your average joe customer all day, every day. Whenever Im in there Im kind and considerate, even if my order is wrong. So in return, the staff is not rude to me. Wild notion, isnt it?
AN
Anthony S
Food was below average for standard pizza/sub shops. I ordered a buffalo chicken cheesesteak, came out within minutes which was good although it had additional unlisted ingredients such as onions and tomatoes. The guy I spoke with to have corrected tried telling me thats how it always comes and thats how its listed on the menu. We both checked the menu and those ingredients werent listed... He did correct the sub. So if you go to eat here be sure to order exactly how u want your food.
AY
Aya Ceres
The food can be very good at P and Js. I never have a problem when Victor is working. But be careful because if Guiseppie is working he will rip you off. I ordered a small and medium pizza from them and he charged me $30+ dollars for something that should have been around $20. Needless to say I wont be going back to them anytime soon.
J
J P
The pizza, ironically, is generally terrible. But the sandwiches are absolutely amazing and the portion sizes are phenomenal. The prices are generally good and the service is swell. Recommended for their hot and cold subs.
MA
Marissa Rafferty
The people on the phone were not very pleasant to talk to. They hung up on me while I was ordering and when I called back they were stern and didnt sound happy to hear from a paying customer.
CI
Cindy Walter
Really used to love their steak sandwiches but got 3 large ones this past week and there wasnt hardly any meat in them. Very disappointed.
A
A Private User
Worst tasting pizza in etown. The owners are rude and hostile. I would never recommend anyone to go there! Dont waste your money here!
JA
James Horton
Just eating a slice of pepperoni right now. These guys make a great pizza and the staff are real friendly. I recommend it!
LO
Local Consumer
From a real Italian- Elizabethtowns best pizza. Tried it all, and P&J never fail! EDIT: Could work on customer service!
BR
Brian Chalk
Food is good but place is dirty. Guy making pizza was handling the phone and money without washing hands in between.
JE
Jennifer Hummel
Goodf food but they wont deliver. Not even to a house thats only a few miles away! Seriously?
BR
Bryan Brown
I think they have the best subs around the area. Will drive far to get a sub from them.
PA
Paul Robert Miller
While I remember the food being acceptable, the delivery requirements were ridiculous.
ED
Ed Dietrich
Love the sandwiches and decent pizza, but the calzones are not so great.
SH
Shaun Minnich
Good pie, great price. Cant beat the Sunday 5.99 cash large cheese deal
DA
Dan Tschop
My favorite pizza in E-town, but the service can be lacking sometimes.
ST
Stephanie Logan
Great sandwhich/sub/pizza place with old school pizza shop atmosphere
A
A Private User
... consistently good food. Service is often rude to customers.
MJ
mj b
We were regulars for several years and wont return. Horrible.
A
A Private User
So rude on the phone that I actually cancelled my order.
NA
Nathan Bare
Good food. Not a long wait. Very reasonably priced.
JO
John Gerdes
Good pizza and salad. Opened n day after Christmas.
A
A Private User
If you want some good food in etown go to p&js
ST
Stephen Lundy
Clean and friendly okay food for a good price
MA
Matthew Lenker
Good food, probably the best pizza in town.
FR
Frank Hess
Small town pizza shop. That says it all.
MI
Michael Martin
Pizza and cheese steak are awesome
LA
Latroy Wilson
Great lunch special. Fast service.
CO
Corey Acri
Slices were small. .good enuff tho
SA
Sam Sattazahn
Best subs ever for a great price!
JE
Jennifer ritter
Best pizza Ive had in e-town
ST
staks paper
Sometimes, theyre too busy.
MI
mike hess
Very mediocre pizza shop.
TR
Tron Bernhard
Good pizza and great subs
JA
janice matthews
Great pizza and salad s
DA
Dan Figard
Great pizza
A
A Private User
Great food.
A
A Private User
Great food
WI
William Gipe
Good food
AN
Anne Luepnitz
De-lish
BE
Benjamin Boyer
