Pizza Cottage
| Address: | 4592 Walnut Rd, Buckeye Lake, OH 43008, USA |
| Phone: | +1 740-928-1144 |
| Site: | pizza-cottage.com |
| Rating: | 4.4 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 60
KE
Kelly Spangler
Two weekends in a row now weve ordered pizza and wings from here, the food is great but they cant seem to get the order right. The first time they "forgot" a pizza after we asked them if that was all at the window, along with giving us the wrong order of wings. We had to drive 30 minutes back to the restaurant only to be received with rude attitudes. The second time they once again gave us the wrong type of wings, and we would have had to go back to the store to switch them out again. Decided we are never ordering from them again! Their food isnt worth the poor service and constantly getting the wrong order.
TE
Terra Shandra
The food was excellent! The first waitress was not very good, another lady took over - she was very good. The BLT pizza was awesome!! The sub sandwich was perfect. The salad ingredients were fresh.. they put tomato slices on tour salad. My family and I really enjoyed out stay and plan to go back when in that area.
JA
James Shepherd
I found them a month ago and was delighted with the food and delivery.....now on friday, they say they have 10 deliveries ahead of me. 10 deliveries on friday is not a big backup. They said call back in 2 hours....I say,screw you !!! Your piss poor management sent my money somewhere else. Seriously screw you !!!
A
A Private User
I have went to pizza cottage for over a decade and have been extremely satisfied almost every time. The last time I went the pizza was delicious, but my waitress was very rude towards my party. Recommendations; Regular Pepperoni Pizza, BLT, Pizza Sub, Italian Sub.
CA
Carl Hamilton
Alert... Alert I tried to order at pizza cottage for delivery. They refused saying they only deliver to businesses. I have a business ,and business license, but they said no sorry... we ONLY deliver to BARS OR HOTELS... thats discriminating! I will be reporting!
LA
Laura G. & John D. Zarlino, CP
The Pizza Cottage in the Buckeye Lake Region is a wonderful place to visit on a daily basis not just a once-in-a-while event I always keep the menus popping with new and tasty items very customer-centric and attentive to your needs Fair portions for a fair price
DA
Dave k
I ride my motorcycle to Pizza Cottage every summer from Columbus. I always get the Italian sub. It is really good. Ive had their pizza before and it like it as well. It ride over to the State Park by the lake and have my sub there.
AI
Air Management Heating and Cooling
Best Pizza around! For a new pizza experience try the BLT pizza. Whether youre looking for a "normal" pizza or a specialty - this is the place to go. Always great food and great service.
JA
Jake Smith
Local Legend if your in central Ohio and want good pizza. This is it. This pizza is far different from big chain or ma n pa pizzas its pizza cottage! pay for the differance and see.
A
A Private User
Been eating here for over 20 years and I dont think the quality is nothing what it used to be,the blt taste like dirt anymore used to be 20 times better,last three Ive had suck
?
宮本力
とにかくボリュームたっぷりです。 テイクアウトしたくなるぐらい❗️ 味は濃いめですかね❗️
DE
Deb Johnston
Ordered chicken pizza got ham uggggg second last time ordering pizza here we really love the dessert pizza..But how hard is it to punch in CHICKEN...SMH
CH
Chad Lines
It was so bad. I have been coming to the pizza cottage for years and i dont see my self and my family will not come back the food was nasty!!
RO
roger mattison
Very tasty steak sub "Marthas way "? Was very satisfied. I see they have live entertainment several nights a week. Would recommend highly
CA
Cassie Kohen
Its to me over priced on drinks I got a tall draft beer and most places are around 3 well theirs is 4.50 for one. pizza prices r average
JE
Jeremy Donnell
Very good... Great selection. Beer is cold. Pizza is on POINT! The service was quick and the family smashed all the food! Will come back!
TR
Travis Lane
Foods fantastic, wait staff was slow due to the event but orders arrived quick. Really recommend their sweet Thai chili chicken!
TR
Tracy Euman
The food is great and the service is excellent. My mom and I go there quite often. Love their pizza and salads
MA
Madalyn Mikkelsen
Service was good food was good, but a little expensive. You can tell that the food is premade and then just heated and served.
CA
Carolyn Fox
Consistently good food and friendly staff. I recommend this place to family and friends. BLT pizza is a must try, excellent.
LE
Leslie Boey
Great service and amazing pizza. Get the BLT pizza. You wont regret it. A family friendly place, great for groups
JE
Jeff Hunter
Ruthies way is the only way! pizzas fantastic my daughter normally dont eat pizza unless its pizza cottage
KE
ken crane
Had the Margherita pizza for the first time tonight, it was FABULOUS!!! Best Pizza I have ever had here!!
ST
starr peterson
Pizza was awesomely delicious! Wings was in a set of 5 which I thought was a weird number. Usually is 6.
WI
William Settles
Salads and a Calzone! All yummy! Calzones are to your order for contents. Beer was ice cold too...,!
AL
Alex C. Moreno
Good unhealthy pizza! Oh yeah. and the have a very unique pizza, the BLT pizza. You must try it.
JA
Jayme Muncie
The best of all the Pizza Cottage locations. Always friendly, always consistent and always great!!
IB
ibcassiegpa
It hasnt been as good in recent months. Not sure whats being changed but not as good as it was.
JA
James White
Grew up on Pizza Cottage in Lancaster. Just the best.Love just about everything on the menu.
MI
Mike Mcgonigle
Very good pizza and subs. Fast service and great dining room. Very good servers too.
PA
Paganmoon73
The best wings I have ever had period. The whole hog pizza is ridiculously good.
BE
Betty Obradovich
Pizza was fantastic!! Beer only, no wine. Service was good on a Sunday evening.
SA
Sammy deboard
I am a team member of pizza cottage and I absolutely love the food, and people!
ZA
Zach Isaacs
Anytime I come down from Canton to visit the family a blt pizza is a must
WA
Walter Greenfield
Super pizza, great crust, always fresh ingredients. Outstanding flavor.
TH
Theresa Grace
We had the chance to eat here and we loved the BLT pizza, great job!
JO
john graber
Very good food, pizzas made the way you like them. Thank you, Graber
KA
Kathy Willey
Had very good service. Food was served promptly and was very good.
DA
Dan Bey
Great pizza and atmosphere. The service has always been good, too!
GR
Greg M
Grade-A Ohio style pizza, some of the best in the Columbus area.
DO
Donnie Scarberry
Very good place. Been going there for as long as I can remember.
DO
DODSTIL DEMPSEY
Very friendly atmosphere, friendly servers, and excellent pizza.
DR
Drew Frank
Nice and relaxed, with relatively cheap prices, and good food.
PI
Pinky Lee
I dont think the food is as good as before they commercialized
PA
Patterson Andrea
Great pizza! Very busy place, booths are tiny, but fantastic!
KU
Kurt Kauffman
Excellent pizza and spaghetti. Delicious wings. Cold beer.
JA
Jake Flowers
Food is great but I wish they would do more karaoke nights.
AN
Andrew amos
Its always awesome food is great an service is on the spot
LE
lexxi eades
Good is good but hella greasy gave me diarrhea like a mf
MI
Mike Ashcraft
Amazing pizza. Only down side is the limited seating.
AM
Amy Parsons
The food and service were both excellent as always!
A
A Private User
This is the best Pizza!! Try the salads too -
JO
John Mathews
One of the best pizza places in Central Ohio
JA
Jay Dee
11 out of 10. Worth every penny. Great Pizza!
JO
John Bradshaw
Really good food, quick friendly service
JE
Jerrid Cook
Love this place. Great pizza great staff
MI
mike couch
I love the pep pizza. So spicy. So good!
GE
georgia carol rose
The food is awesome !!! Love the pizza
BA
Barbara Richnow
Wonderful crisp, not soggy, calzone!!
PA
Paul Moretti
BLT pizza is the best pizza around
