Noble Pies Bakery and Cafe

Reviews 17

A

A Private User

while wandering the warwick countryside i stumbled across a small pie shop.being a person of extreme love of all things pie i entered.and realized i was in a very special place.First the aroma of fresh baking pies then the sight of various fruit pies,muffins,scones,cookies and strudels.i just knew this was the beginning of a new ritual of weekly visits.i have declared Friday as Pieday.and make the 45 minute trek from Haskell n.j.to Warwick n.y.with anticipation of a new favorite every week.if i may just hit some high notes i have discovered..Apple- pear just amazing,apple-cranberry...wow and on a cold winters day i opted for a chicken pot pie instead of a sweet selection...probably the best thing i have eaten in my 47 years on this planet...this might sound a little extreme,but if you visit,you will thank me the folks at NOBLE PIES,GOT IT RIGHT...NUFF SAID!!!!!!

---

A

A Private User

RUDE customer service. The door was open on a Monday evening after we went food shopping at Price Chopper. We had walked in since the door was ajar. We saw that there were no customers and it was a bit late in the evening around 7pm. We asked if he was still open. He simply said "No." and continued with whatever he was doing. (Mind you this was the week of his grand opening.) He did not offer to give us a list of pies, or when he would be open next, or even menu or pamphlet. He just simply ignored us after the "No." Did not even apologize or say goodbye. I personally would rather bake my own pie than purchase and support a business which does not care for its customers. I will not purchase any pastries from this location nor or in the future.

---

CI

Cindy Krikava

Was visiting my sister and bought an apple pie to bring for the next day. When we brought out the pie, I was wondering why it looked so dark under the pie crust. One bite told the tale. It was mold. I dont think their pie cases are refrigerated, and they probably dont much worry about "sell by" dates. Very off-putting. Had a cherry pie months before and was told about the work to get the pits out of the cherries. However, it didnt taste very good. Seemed like just cooked cherries in there, no sauce, and I hate deserts that are too sweet, but I dont think there was any sugar at all. (like the savory pies though....Shepherds pie and Cottage pie)

---

PA

Patricia Moriarty-Boles

Unbelievable pies, their pie crusts are so rich and pleasantly sweet, pies are so dense filled with lots and lots of fruit. Barely able to eat a normal size slice. Delicious muffins, cookies, dinner pies...all wonderful. Expensive but worth every penny! The owners work tirelessly and are warm and friendly!

---

ZA

Zachary Bonder

Leslie Noble makes the best pies on earth. Family owned and operated with the freshest ingredients they can find. I have no problem paying a few extra dollars for fresh ingredients. This is the real deal.

---

MI

Mike Carfi

Banofee Pie.......Holy ****.....I want an IV hooked up with Banofee Pie in the bag..... AMAZING. Please support this vendor, because making pie is such an art, and when its done properly, it makes me

---

BR

bruce karlan

Not only are their products the best on the planet these are the nicest most accommodating people you will meet at any business established!

---

LU

Lu Brewster

BEST PIES ON THE PLANET!!! My family goes each year for SEVERAL Christmas pies and have never been disappointed.

---

RO

Ron Bertot

Awesome pies...Both savory and dessert pies are excellent

---

DI

Diane Davidson

Absolutely love everything in this store!

---

MI

Michael McGee

An excellent selection of fantastic pies.

---

RI

Richard Contrata

Tried the apple pie. It was incredible.

---

GE

Geoffrey Green

You will not find a better apple pie.

---

KA

Kathryn Metcalfe

Best pies on planet Earth. Period.

---

SC

Scot Keith

Best pies in the Hudson Valley

---

KE

Ken Freeman

Friendly staff and great pies

---

DA

Danielle Barbour

Yummiest pie ever!

---

---