Piece-A-Cake

177 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA

Address:	177 New Dorp Ln, Staten Island, NY 10306, USA
Phone:	+1 718-980-2253
Site:	pieceacakenyc.com
Rating:	4.2
Working:	8AM–9PM 8AM–9PM 8AM–9PM 8AM–9PM 8AM–10PM 8AM–10PM 8AM–9PM

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 36

Sarah Stalerman

This place as a lot of delious and reasonably priced baked goods and sweets (many being around $3). They also offer breakfast and lunch menus. Many customers stay there to eat thier delious desserts in the bakerys retro and somewhat hipster atmosphere. The place is full of fun and cute decorations most notably busting of a red superman loving phone boot, a subway sign, a tall fireplace, and a life sized statue of a man seating atop the rafters. Although most of their food is great, among the most amazing and popular are their french toast and pancakes (accompanied by buttery egg batter), NYC cheesecake, red velvet shake, and focaccia.

Abba Dalla

If you go here for the sit down, dont. My rating is combined food and service. Sitting down sometimes is a trial of patience. However on a good note the pastries are awesome, must have a good balance of sweet, taste, and freshness-they also have ice cream and dessert shop drinks(coffee, tea, juice, etc). They have some classics and lots of cake slices. Their best food item is the focaccia bread, but their all day breakfast is great when you can get a table with service.

Catherine Howe

Ordered a last minute cake for 35 people to celebrate my daughters engagement. The cake looked beautiful and more importantly tasted great. Everyone commented how delicious and fresh it tasted. I ordered over the phone and asked the girl what their most popular cake was and she recommended the french cream with blueberries and strawberries. Will order from them again.

Stacy Tolas

Great Experience. I am so impressed by the level of professionalism and knowledge Olivia has. She was so helpful on helping design my cake with the look I wanted for an affordable price. The cake was so beautiful & so delicious. I loved it as did my guests. The cupcakes were also amazing. I cant imagine going elsewhere the next time I need a cake.

Crystal Cun

Cute multipurpose bakery/coffee shop/cafe we wandered in and between the cookies, bars, cakes, hot drinks, soups and sandwiches, pretty much everyone found something they wanted. The Wicked Hot Chocolate ($2) is chocolate with a bit of cayenne, just enough to tickle pleasantly. If youre undecided (or just hungry), theres samples near the front.

Brandon Boschi

It was horrible, I just wanted to sit down with my girlfriend and drink hot chocolate but no. The waitress made us get up and sit on uncomfortable bar stools next to the garbage pale. Meanwhile there were plenty of empty tables. Apparently the tables are only for people who get other things besides drinks.

Olivia Zhou

Ive had brunch here and they make food that is so delicious. They have this great corn chowder that I love but get here early or they run out of soup quick. Their baked goods are unbelievable and if you sit down, they sometimes walk around with free baked goods. Also, the ambience is great!

Brittany Favorito

Food is always delicious and the staff are very friendly. They always pass around free goodies! A little pricey compared to other bakeries but the food and sweets are worth the price. The Italian egg sandwich and the pancakes are my favorite. Also, the red relvet cupcakes are amazing!!!!

mike olsen

Great baked goods and pretty good brunch items as well. Everything is great here but especially the adult chocolate chip cookies which are salted to perfection and the everything cookie which is my everything. If you go make sure you bring cash because it is cash only

Melanie Wahl

Like Cookie Jar, this is one of the best places for baked goods. Did not eat there. Their bubble tea is just OK, but the blood orange was amazing and filled with pulp (i like that). Cream puff was best Ive ever had. Zucchini cake was also delicious.

Moses Asomaning

My baby nephews first birthday cake was ordered from this bakery and they did an amazing job. The staff was really helpful with the order and the decor gives off a Brooklyn vibe. Definitely recommend this place for your bakery needs!!

Tracy King

I was treated real nasty by a staff and will not be back.l spend up to $60.00 a month there.my donuts was packed on top of each other so that they could stick on each other.So nasty how they treat people who dont look like them.

Bren G

Oh my, my, my, my. Its heavenly delicious. Iove it and the staff are sweeties. I do wish they had a nutfree section of desserts and splenda sugar free items. But nonetheless. I love this place..

Vincent Militello

Great place beautiful designing and awesome food love the chicken Philly and adult chocolate chip cookies are delicious ask for Keri she is one of the best waitresses in there always so helpful

Christine Hafele

I am always stopping in for something. They are affordable and it is homey. The workers are wonderful and their food is delicious!!! I have never ordered something I did not absolutely love!!!

Aaron Shab

I really like the place, great ambiance and staff. One of the few places that caters well to a modern young adult crowd but they dont accept credit cards otherwise a 5 star establishment.

Private User M.D.

Omg! The BEST TASTING cannolis, cream puffs, donuts, so soft and not overly sweet! Finally, an excellent bakery in my neighborhood! Breakfast menu looks really good too, must try!!

Nicole Vaynshtok

Best breakfast Ive had in a very long time. Food is so fresh, waffles were airy, the sauce that comes with it is incredible. So glad I was shown this place

David Badiola

Great service, great people, great food, and great reputation. One of the great Staten Island places to chill and have sweet foods while doing so.

Blerim Cukovic

Its a great place. They have great variety along with great service. The dessert items make you as gluttonous as you can get. Great prices too!

CletusT Paramedic

Food is overpriced, tables are for customers who order more than one thing, and the workers are rude and pushy as hell. Never coming back here.

adeline cambria

Very artistic place, the food was amazing and the service was super friendly. Definitely try the sluttybrownie best thing Ive ever tasted!

Nick Chiarchiaro

Pristine----helpful staff and the "cakes" are to die for . Especially the cheese and the apple rings!!!!!!

Kayla Khaled

So delicious and not too expensive. Cash only. They do brunch but dessert is why you should stop in.