The Pie
| Address: | 216 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-331-4646 |
| Site: | thepieofportjeff.com |
| Rating: | 4 |
| Working: | 11:30AM–9:30PM 11:30AM–9:30PM 11:30AM–9:30PM 11:30AM–9:30PM 11:30AM–10:30PM 11:30AM–10:30PM 11:30AM–9:30PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 39
ST
Steven Guarneri
The Pie is really an excellent place to enjoy a nice meal with friends and family. Ive been coming here since 2009 and I have never been disappointed. I am always greeted with prompt and friendly service and usually seated right away! The last time I went I got a house salad and BBQ pizza was delightful. The savory sweet tangy BBQ chicken glides across your pallet and when washed down with a crisp pinot griggio it makes for a complete culinary experience. Keep up the great work ! Until next time, -Steven Guarneri
MI
Michelle Conway
Great little place! I was here with my family on a busy Tuesday evening in August. We were seated immediately in a large booth. It was noisy, which was great because we have small children they would not be heard over the din. Coincidentally, the kids were quiet because they give the kids wikki stix instead of a coloring page. We ordered mozzarella caprese as an appetizer and a large margherita pizza. Both were delicious. It all came to right under $40 with the food, two sodas, a milk and a juice.
A
A Private User
We ordered their special spinach salad two glasses of wine and a margherita pizza..Service was friendly and cordial.. Salad was great, with warm roasted onion and a good gargonzola vingarette.. The pizza arrived when we were three bites into the salad.. The crust was cooked ahead of time, with the fresh toppings added and then rehheated.. the sauce used was purely jarred or canned.. we sent it back, they graciously removed it from the bill we left and had a great meal at pace steak house..
JA
Jacob Kraniak
Very underwhelming. Got the small BBQ Style pizza and thought it tasted... Fine but for $16 I expect a much bigger portion. The small pizza was maybe 8" in diameter and had thin crust. I wouldnt pay more than $8 for a similar pizza anywhere else. Decor and atmosphere was nice and the service was pretty quick for myself and my fiance after 20min on a Friday night. Very average and underwhelming overall.
ST
Stephanie Cocchi
Disappointed with the visit. It had such great reviews. The garlic bread, caesar salad and mozzarella sticks were good. The service was not and the pizza was abysmal. Not one of 4 children finished a slice and they are small slices. It is ridiculously over priced for the food they serve, Port Jefferson can be pricey but this seemed outrageously so, it is after all still just pizza. I would not go again.
RA
Ralph Taylor
LI Business Group would like to thank Kristen Pace and her staff for donating her time and Pizza to our 2nd annual fund raiser. This year our Charity was Friends of Kenny Warren which is a Charity whos mission is to help 10,000 children that have been stricken with Cancer. Kristen , your food and generosity was incredible. Everyone loved it. Thank you again, Ralph Taylor
A
A Private User
This is my favorite pizzeria ever...in my dining out experiences at The Pie, the one thing that keeps me coming back is the service! One of the managers, Joe, always make our children very happy by taking them into the kitchen to see how pizza pies are made! My kids never have a dull moment here thanks to Joe who always welcomes us back as we are now regulars!
SU
Sunny Patel
My food reviews are subjective relating to the area the restaurant is in. This is one of the best pizzerias in the Stony Brook / Port Jefferson area. Excellent margherita pizza, good prices for lunch. But these are expected from any good pizzeria. They also had a delicious apple cobbler ice cream desert (picture posted) which was brought out by one of the chefs.
A
A Private User
Great brick oven pizzas, pastas, etc. Very nice atmosphere and in beautiful Port Jeff. Prices are moderate and depend on the type of pie. Expect to pay about $15-20pp incl. tax and tip. Small pies are not available at dinner, only at lunch. Be sure to walk down along the docks after eating and grab ice cream, fro-yo or italian ice, too.
LY
Lynne Hubbard
With pizza places a dime-a dozen and one within a mile of another, its nice to know that when I eat a pie from "The Pie" I always know what Im getting.. consistently, well-made thin crust pizza, with all ingredients fresh...staff always pleasant as well...
LU
Luis Cabrera
Buen sabor en la comida tienen rica salsa, aunque el jugo de limón tienen q mejorarle el gusto y un precio razonable
CA
Carmine Campisi
First time dining at the pie. Loud atmosphere and that was fine. Started with a small Margarita pie. Dined on Pasta with sausage and Broccoli Rabe. Great choice. They also had specials that sounded delicious as well. We will definitely be back.
HE
Helen Flores
Service was horrible, employees seemed to be more concerned about socializing than serving the customer. For a place that was supposed to specialize in gourmet pizza, the pizzas were average, there is more variety in my local pizza place.
RI
Richard Pigott
Pizza is excellent!!! It is cooked in the healthier European manner consisting of very thin dough & more toppings which is very different from American pizza which is mostly bread.
ER
Erin Brewer
We had a charming and fun waiter named Michael who made our dinner at The pie a wonderful experience. Great salads and of course the pizza was great.
LE
Leonel Funes
I being here alot for the pass 5 years and this is my favorite place for great pizza i love there buffalo pie with the chicken
RO
Robert Zeller
Good coal-fired pizza. The "wild mushrooms" were clearly store-bought Bellas, though.
KR
Kristen Medeiros
Great mussels and great pizza. Large dining room and very accommodating for children.
RO
Robert Keuler
High price for what you get. I got a medium Pizza and 2 sodas for $30. Nuff said.
PE
Peter Healy
First time here, great place. We had a Spinichi pie and it was dynamite.
DI
dielon117
Amazing food, atmosphere, great prices, and awesome staff
BR
Bryce Thuilot
If you like thin curst pizza this is the place to go to
KE
kev bre
Michael was the best waiter and the pizza was great.
TO
Tony Cacaccio
Good atmosphere, friendly staff, and tasty Italian.
JA
Jay Cujo
Great Italian food! The fried mozzarella is awesome
JA
Jake Butkevich
Great pizza as well as other Italian dishes
CH
Christine Kern
Always, excellent coal-fired pizza.
ER
Eric Bartlett
This is not a good place to stay at
AN
Andrea Battifarano
Nice atmosphere. Delicious pizza.
AP
April Delia
Love the shrimp and garlic pie!!
HU
Huda Anwar
Love all the food they serve.
NO
Noe Cruz
Excellent pie!
JO
Joe Barilla
Pretty good!
A
A Private User
Great pizza
TO
Tom Butkevich
Good pies.
TH
THE GLOBEL ENTERTAINMENT
Horrible
LO
Lost Gorilla
Horribke
DO
Doreen Kuzman
Yummy
NI
Nicole Dramis
Yummy
