Five brothers pizza and pasta
| Address: | 2505 Carmel Ave #107, Brewster, NY 10509, USA |
| Phone: | +1 845-278-4500 |
| Site: | 5brotherspizzaandpasta.com |
| Rating: | 4.2 |
| Working: | 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM 11AM–9:30PM |
Location
Photos 46
Reviews 9
A
A B
If I could give a negative star I absolutely would. We live about a few minutes away from this pizzeria so obviously we have done a lot of business with the old owners (who were fantastic) and also business with these new owners. We have given them several chances but tonight was the LAST straw. As a side note before I get into what happened tonight, this is what has happened in the past; wrong food, completely messed up food such as pasta not properly enclosed in its dish so its all over the bag, unprofessional attitude over the phone, 1 hour late deliveries when they say 20-30 minutes, the list goes on. So, tonight, we ordered from them giving them one last chance and my GOD are we DONE. We ordered tonight a pie now my family and I totally understand that its the day after Christmas we doubt that anybody would be cooking today, however dont say about 30 minutes maybe less when it took you over an hour to get here, okay? Next, our pies had NO toppings that we asked for on it but did we get charged for it? Of course we did. Now my stomach for some reason almost always hurts after eating their pizza for strange reason so I dont eat a lot of it but today I did not eat any of it due to the fact that it had some strange strange taste to it almost fishy-esque. My brother on the other hand did not encounter the joy of the fishy taste however he did find a nice piece of hair and a horrible stomach ache to match. Why didnt we call them to complain? We are TIRED of complaining! They NEVER do anything to compensate for the screw ups nor anything to make the situation better. Its so sad to know that the pizzeria that we have used since I was young has been left in a new name with horrible quality. You just lost customers.
JO
John Doe
Good pizza for upstate. The "Grandmas Pie" is stand out. Chicken wings are delicious as well. Friendly staff.
PR
Privacy Privacy
Nice new owners the nicest quality cheese and tomato sauce I suggest Bacon chicken ranch best pizza
JA
Jack R
Really Good Pizza! but their wings are the Best Ive ever had!!! Great job guys, Thanx!!
RO
Rodrigo Rodriguez
About time someone cleaned the place up. Welcoming staff. BEST PIZZA IN BREWSTER!
A
A Private User
The Best Pizza in Brewster and 12.50 is the average price for pizza these days...
MA
Matthew Myer
When it was Brewster Square good people, dont know much about the new crew
JI
Jim Thompson
Awsome food has delivery service also if you dont wanna leave work or home
DI
Diego Rod
Friendly staff is always very welcoming. Pizza is top notch for our area.
