The Penny Pub
| Address: | 79 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-969-4061 |
| Site: | thepennypub.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | 11:30AM–4AM 11:30AM–4AM 11:30AM–4AM 11:30AM–4AM 11:30AM–4AM 11:30AM–4AM 11:30AM–4AM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 28
FR
Franklin Bonilla
The service was great & friendly. Nice little place that definitely feels like an Irish pub. The best pint of Guinness Ive had. The only downside I would say is that they only accept cash. No credit cards. But they do have an ATM inside.
A
A Private User
I have never been to Ireland but I would imagine its the only place on Long Island where you can get a pint of guinness just like you would get in Ireland
NI
Nicholas Testut
Bartenders are great, drinks were reasonably priced. Atmosphere was amazing, not overly packed for a busy night. Plenty of sitting room.
DA
Dan Lee
Not sure the black stuff is like back in Dublin as some claim but its not bad I guess. Typical faux Irish Bar that does its best.
SA
Samantha Sigelakis-Minski
This is a main street staple of Bay Shore. Dirty, divey, simple Irish pub where you can get a pint and a good darts game.
RI
Rishma Ramoutar
Went here lat night with some good friends for the first time! Good music and good drinks! Will go to this pub again ;)
JA
Jason Phillips
One of the bestime bars in bay shore. Awesome bartenders. Great late night food.
AL
Alex Antonelli
Fine pints of the black stuff. Adrian is the signature bartender.
MI
Michael Vargas
New addition of Bar food is a home run. Best mac and cheese ever.
CH
Christopher Andrews
Great service, nice selection. Lots of locals and all friendly.
DE
Denny Bennett
Excellent jumbo size hamburgers and friendly bartenders.
TI
Timothy Cornetto
Great food and drinks, great atmosphere. I love it.
CR
Craig Frey
Adrian is the best. Greatest bartender around.
RI
Richard Rommeney
Great Irish Pub in the Heart of Bay Shore
A
A Private User
Just the real deal a Irish pub at its best
RO
Robert LaBoy Jr
Small cozy, comfortable, and personable.
PE
Peter Santo
The best there ever is and ever will be
RI
Richard Peck
Great selection of beers, a proper pub
A
A Private User
Great place to end a crazy night
AU
August Pisano
The bartender Jill shes amazing
BR
Brian Lomot
Great Bourbon and Drink Menu
HE
herbie hennessy
Fried Mac and cheese!
CH
Christian Limbach
Always charmed
RI
Rich Koos
Not worth it.
CH
Christian Andersen
Cool dive bar
EN
Eng.Sayed Mohamed AlZalzalah
Can be better
BU
Butch Dougan
Great bar
BK
BK HVAC
just ok
