StuffedBurger - 100% Grass Fed
| Address: | 150 Valley Rd #1, Montclair, NJ 07042, USA |
| Phone: | +1 973-893-5805 |
| Site: | stuffedgrassfedburgers.com |
| Rating: | 4.1 |
| Working: | 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–9PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–8PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 25
JA
Jacqueline Rousseau
I had mine delivered via Uber Eats; I dont know if that makes a difference in my experience, but this is the first review Ive ever given (thats how bad it was). So, I got a classic burger stuffed with cheddar and some L & T on top. I added an extra slice of cheese because I love cheese and it was only $0.50. Good thing I got that extra slice, because there was no cheese stuffed in the middle! Whatever, this in and of itself wouldnt have been a big deal because maybe I selected the wrong options when checking out. The burger, in and of itself, however, was terrible. It tasted like there was pickles or relish ground up in the actual patty. Maybe that is a non-issue if you like pickles and relish, but I do not. Not to mention, the burger was barely medium rare. I like medium rare burgers, but this was borderline inedible. I did foray into the middle of the burger on my hunt for the nonexistent cheese stuffing, but if I was served this in the actual restaurant, I wouldve asked for it to be cooked a bit longer. Besides the actual burger, the lettuce was brown and wilty. At first I thought it was just soaked in burger juice, but upon closer inspection, it really seemed quite old and not crisp. I have to give full points for the tomato slice, though. Give credit where it is due. And of course, the bun. My poor potato bun was so soggy it was like mush. I couldnt take the burger out of the wrapper. Again, this couldve been caused by the fact that I had delivery, but it might have also been avoided if the burger was actually medium rare or medium instead of rare. Also, it takes like 2 minutes to toast a bun on the grill and that prevents it from dissolving in the juices. Once I realized there wasnt an ooey-gooey cheese center for me to find, I tossed the rest of the burger. Now Im munching on the fries, which are quite overcooked. (And soggy, although Ill chalk that up to the fact that I had it delivered.) Overall, you would be hard pressed to convince me to try this place again, and usually Im always up for second chances. My food was just so completely bad outside of the delivery excuses that I dont even really want to see if they make a better burger in the actual restaurant.
EA
Earl Grosser
Burger was pretty good, although were had ones that were quite better. The burger I had cake plain on the plate. Zero presentation and quite small. I could easily easy two and would need fries as well. The area is crowded with not much seating and quite you may think they have no bathroom they did, but you have to walk through the kitchen to get to it. Who designed this place? The woman serving us was polite and patient which is important, sometimes more than food. They have had Groupons in the past but we paid full price this time. I was debating about 3 or 4 stars but for the money we spent, we felt there should be more satisfaction for it.
AN
Ann Mooney
I had the Classic Burger and the ingredients were good quality with the right seasoning. I carried it out as I am staying near the restaurant temporarily . The temperature was still hot when I arrived home. Sweet potato fries were crisp and delicious. This former Texas food truck entrepreneur is spirited and committed to his mission of bringing an enjoyable burger experience to his home town of Montclair. Tonight he was committing profits to the flood crisis in Texas. I liked that as my family is from Houston. Good healthy food and community on Valley Road!
BI
Bilal Ersoy
ive been here a couple of times with the same order every time. An original stuffed burger with fries and a drink. Usually comes up to $12. The last time i visited i payed $17 in total for a burger fries and a drink. Thats bullshit. I asked the girl if there was a mistake and she had told me that was the price. Im not eating a gourmet styled dish here. Not coming here again either dont wast your time for an over priced burger you can get for $6 at a diner. Stay clear.
DA
Dave P
Best burger joint in the area, we order here a few times a week and every time it comes surprisingly quick and delicious as ever. I have ordered from here four times in a row at one point and was perfectly happy with all orders, never got sick of it. I will always be a stuffed supporter
JI
Jim Read
Its a gimmick and poorly executed. The burgers are overworked and overcooked, the result is a hard, dry burger. On a second visit, I tried a non-stufded burger, thinking itd be better...it wasnt. The brioche bun from balthazar is the right choice and was delicious.
JE
Jessica Walch
The burgers were pretty good but the portions were on the small side. The restaurant itself feels like a cheap fast food place. It seems like they want to be like SmashBurger but the execution isnt totally there.
LI
Liam Crowe
The burgers are great. Shakes get a a+. The only problem I had was the front desk. The guy was kind of shaking and shuttering. But, the food makes up for it. Final score: A-
AL
Alex R
Thought the burguers would be a bit bigger but they make up in the flavor. brisket burguer was awesome and so were the fries and sweet potatoe fries, onion rings are banging.
P
P Emanuel
Very good food, very good service from the friendly staff. The burger was a tad bit over cooked for my taste but it wouldnt stop me from giving them another shot.
MA
Maria Campos
The Brisket Burger I had was absolutely amazing, it was juicy and cheesy. I could barely finish the whole thing! Paired with a creamy milkshake, it made my day!
SE
Sean Johnstone
Staff is very friendly and polite. Burgers are phenomenal, cooked perfectly and the combinations are truly genius. Man n Cheese eggrolls are also a must try!
AL
Alan Sato
I got the classic stuffed burger and my girlfriend got the breakfast burger. Both were great. Got the brisket fries as well. Overall left well fed and happy
JA
Jay Jaay
Burger was juicy and delicious. Service was good and friendly. I would definitely go again and create my own burger. The bacon jam iss ahhhmazing!!!
DA
Dale Billiard
Love their milkshakes - simple, yet refreshing. I also had their donut burger, which was a unique amalgamation of sweet, savory and hearty.
HE
Helen Garcia
Really good burger, first time trying since starting to work in Montclair. If you pass by this town make sure to stop by this place.
MA
Max Dorsey-Gordon
Id like to try it a few more times. But the food that I had was delicious and the price was comparable for what we received.
C.
C. P.
Awesome Burger. The Owner & his staff were very professional. I recommend this to all who wants a delicious burger!
JO
Jorge Correa
I had the montclair blue burger, it was great but for a $11 burger I would expect the fries to be included.
AN
Anthony Spano
Excellent spot, quality burgers, reasonably priced, you get what you pay for. I will be back for sure.
XR
XRayTiD
Burgers were not as good as expected given their rating, Ive had better at Diners in the area
ST
Stephen Luke
Great burgers. The doughnut burger is fantastic, and special burgers keep the menu fresh.
DA
David Singletary
Great burger! I had the bacon cheddar burger with fried egg. Friendly staff.
RI
Riya Freire
Burgers were amazing!! My suggestion, try the french toast burger!!
TO
tony hagy
Great food and there you dont have to pay so much for good food
