Bay Ave Bakery & Cafe

Address:	111 Bay Ave, Highlands, NJ 07732, USA
Phone:	+1 732-291-3480
Site:	bayavenuecafe.wordpress.com
Rating:	4.7
Working:	6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM 6:30AM–6PM

Location

Photos 100

Reviews 34

Loren Sheridan

Dont eat outside! When the hostess hesitated when we asked if we could eat outside we should have known. After seating us, she took our drink order and told us our server would be with us shortly. Ten minutes later, my husband went inside to see if they forgot about us. The hostess apologized and came out to take our order. Half an hour later, we left, having still not gotten our food.

Jenn

Best scrambled eggs, light and fluffy. If you are in the Sea Bright NJ area you need to visit this bakery for breakfast. When theyre busy youll wait a bit for food, but its totally worth it. Each plate is served with fresh fruit. Coffee was excellent and the service was good too. Winner all around!

Tara Geraghty

So glad we found this gem. Wanting a Sunday brunch that didnt involve a lot of crowds, waits & tourists we decided to pop in here. Great food and selection. We loved being able to eat outside and we even took some yummy bakery items to go.

edward parsons

Do not come here...unless you are seriously hungry! The portions are huge and the prices are small! The fresh baked yummies are just a tease for the senses. Grab a seat and enjoy some home cooked fare. You will not leave hungry or broke.

Phil Michel

This is our favorite stop for breakfast and lunch when cycling, dog walking, and going to the Sandy Hook area beaches. Everything is homemade, including all baked goods. Even their dog biscuits.

Matthew DeBow

This place is a true bakery. Breakfast or lunch, everything is excellent, especially the southern style biscuits n gravy with an egg on top!. You must try this place at least once.

Aaron Boyce

Its a local place with good food. It is our go to for breakfast. The only downside is the service isnt always the best and they occasionally run out of specific items from the menu.

Liz Weyer

Great place for locals to grab a yummy bagel or special baked treat. Good coffee, breakfast fare and generous lunch portions. Save 1/2 for dinner and enjoy it all over again.

R.O. Lovelace

Good food, little pricey compared to the unbeatable Zoeys Vintage Cafe in Atlantic Highlands. But please try this one! Bay Ave is great if you are bound by location

Ian Farruggio

Great local spot. Fresh baked bread and bagels are awesome. Lunch is a standout and always try the specials. Best meatball sandwich Ive ever tasted.

Kevin Hamp

Great service and baked goods. Very friendly and good prices on huge variety of baked treats. I recommend the chocolate bomb. Coffee is also excellent.

Jason Shaw

Great food and awesome service....even when packed. Never dissapointed. Inside and sidewalk seating.....I wish they would get a deck setup in the back

Paulette Zazzara

Our weekend home is 100 yards from the cafes door. Weve been there many times. Simply the best. Weve never been disappointed here.

Theresa Meire

This place is aces all around but its the service thatll make you return. Return and get some delicious baked goods!

Joe G

Everything about this spot is superior to any bakery I have visited always fresh and done to perfection

William Bourg

The breakfast is excelent The prices are reasonable, and if you love coffee this is great!

Karen Finkelstein

Service is slow whether crowded or not. Tables not wiped down. The food was good though.

Andrew Baldwin

Wonderful food and service. Bagels are great but try some of their pastries!