Old Town Pizza
| Address: | 514 State Rte 31, McHenry, IL 60050, USA |
| Phone: | +1 815-578-1111 |
| Site: | oldtownpizzaco.com |
| Rating: | 4.2 |
| Working: | 10AM–9:30PM 10AM–9:30PM 10AM–9:30PM 10AM–9:30PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10:30AM–9:30PM |
Location
Photos 4
Reviews 24
CL
Claire R
First time ordering take out was the other night. Needed to try it because I have heard so many people talking about it. I do have to say, honestly, that was one of the best pizzas ever. It felt and tasted fresh and not processed. The toppings were so large that I was full after one slice. I loved the sauce. I will definitely eat there again. No more pizza hut or pap johns for me. I was able to get a large 3 topping for only a few dollars more at old town, yet, I was full after one slice and the size of the canadian bacon was huge! Great job. I will support local businesses!
A
A Private User
Growing up on Olandos pizza in Round Lake Beach I have never come across any pie joint that has come close to making a better pie. We just moved to McHenry and had the need to find a pie shop that was "good enough", but thats not what happend. I came across this place on my phone and seen that all 25 reviews where 5 stars. I figured that someone was lying. Not the case. This is some of the BEST pizza I have ever had. EVER. You have won my dollar for as ling as I live within driving distance. Thank you.
LA
Laura Ziccarelli
Worst delivery experience ever from the Mchenry location. We ordered boneless wings and a double dough pizza. We live under 5 miles away and the order took 75 minutes to get here. We were asked to sign the credit card slip, but the driver didnt have a pen. After finally getting the food inside we found that our "boneless wings" were cut up chicken tenders drizzled in sauce-not even the real kind, the processed nugget kind. It was awful and the pizza wasnt as expected either. Very disappointed.
A
A Private User
Superb; reminiscent of an authentic Chicago Italian "ma & pa" pizzeria, full of flavor and a great thin crust. Having attended several events catered by this Old Town Pizza location, the food was always prepared well and very tasty, from the salad through the entree and sides. The breaded fried zucchini is the best Ive had in many years. I highly recommend this locations fare for carry out, delivery or catered affairs.
A
A Private User
Amazingly fast service - arrived a lot sooner than I expected! Staff was extremely knowledgable and helped me pick out menu items to feed a fairly large crowd(10-15ppl). We had the perfect amount of food - not too little and not too much! Everyone was very pleased with the quality of food and our gathering was a hit! I would definitely recommend to anyone, no matter how many hungry people they have to feed!
JE
Jennifer Kasper
Years ago I remember eating the slices of pizza since I worked near by, then switched jobs and totally forgot about them. In the back of my mind I always thought about how good their pizza was!! I have recently moved back to the area and discovered they deliver!!! The pizza is always fresh an hot!!! It reheats better then any other pizza Ive had and customer service is always great!! So glad to be back!!!
MI
Mike S
Ordered the Deep dish pizza, and it was okay, but the cheese was what was so different. The cheese was not as good as say Lou Mal, or Giordanos pizzas. The cheese was kinda clumpy and not melted all the way. The sauce and bread was good though. Plus it was more expensive then competitors pizzas. Not sure if I will go again..
TO
Tony Don
This place used to be good when the owner put money into it and actually cared. They changed the sauce a year ago which made it worse and somehow more expensive. now its just a bunch of grass smokin clowns who make you wait 10 minutes just to get a soggy slice of pizza.. go 50ft down the street to Jimanos.
CH
Christina Currie
I stop here for pizza on lunch every so often. get the 2 slices. pizza slices are large and delicious. I recommend this over that other place down the road. has more of a natural taste. great service for lunch time. always get a good slice when I walk in. I love pizza and this is a great stop for it.
A
A Private User
I have eaten here more than 6 times and always find it to be a very pleasureable experience. The people are very helpful and in to what they are doing. The food is delicious and made with quality ingredients. I love giving them my money as it ALWAYS feels well worth it.
A
A Private User
Every experience I have had with Old Town Pizza has been excellent! Whether feeding me personally, or supplying my friends and events with quality feasting materials, the food is always hot, delicious, and delivered promptly. Their Italian beef and cheese is HEAVENLY.
HO
Howard Bender
Was in town visiting friends and doing our annual fantasy football draft. Ordered up a large double dough and a large sicilian stuffed for the group. Not only were the pizzas amazing but the delivery time was insanely fast. 12 extremely happy and well-fed men.
BI
Billie Crotty
We have gotten the meal packs and have gotten rave reviws from friends and family slso appreciate they are kind when you call with just a days notice. Have had it delivered so I really dont know about decor but since a response is required Ill assume its good.
A
A Private User
This is one of the best pizza places in McHenry. Not only is the food good, but the people are fantastic. The owner really likes to help out the local schools and other local businesses. I would recommend ordering from Old Town Pizza.
A
A Private User
Best pizza hands down. Always delivered on time, hot and fresh. Their cheesy beef sandwhiches are bomb too....add some fries with cheese sauce for dipping and you will never order from another joint again. I recommend Old Town to everyone!
DR
Drew Klass
Great pizza as well as a ton of great stickers on his cooler when you walk in! Could cut back a little on the cheese but this was really great. Ive had the slices, glad decided to get a whole pie this time around!
JE
Jeremey Bates
Great food and a seriously awesome owner. He really REALLY takes care of his customers, service is 150%. I would highly recommend this business for your every day "slice"of za or for your largest event catering!
A
A Private User
I always get great food there. The slice of pizza and a pop are a good deal too and always ready when I need a quick lunch and the carry-outs are always hot, fresh, and loaded. I recommend it to everyone!
HE
Hellkitten Kitty
Edible, but nothing to get excited about. I have had a hundred pizzas that tasted the same, but those were cheaper. I think the owner is putting in all the good reviews, dont fall for it like we did!
MI
Mike Mertes
Delicious food and extremely nice staff. Easily my favorite pizza place in McHenry county. They always have pizza by the slice, which is great if you want to get a quick but filling pizza fix!
KR
Krystal McCleavy
I ordered a cheesy beef pizza and breaded cauliflower, it was absolutely amazing! I asked to them "brown the cheese" and they made it perfect. Old Town is always my go to pizza place!!
RO
Robert Gattone
This place is my go-to for the family on pizza night. Literally the best pizza in Mchenry County. Also good for a quick slice on my lunch breaks. Great staff and consistently tasty!
A
A Private User
Great pizza at Old Town. Always fresh pies & personable, courteous service. Reasonably priced, accessible location off a major route. Mighty fine establishment.
ST
Stefanie Bartolone
Our company used to have their parties catered by Old Town and the food was so good I started going there for Italian beefs. These guys never let me down.
