Buttermilk Sky Pie
| Address: | 4600 Roswell Rd c130, Sandy Springs, GA 30342, USA |
| Phone: | +1 404-975-3822 |
| Site: | buttermilkskypie.com |
| Rating: | 4.6 |
| Working: | 10AM–9PM 10AM–9PM 10AM–9PM 10AM–9PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM Closed |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 35
LA
Laura Steele
The pies here are delicious, a nice variety of flavors, also. The mini pies are a great size. Cute shop, too, with a nice display of their pies. With it being our first time to the shop, it lacked a little of the friendly welcome feeling, with an explanation of their products/offerings from the staff. We ordered pie with ice cream and it came mixed together in a dish. It was good, definitely a different take on a la mode, but this seemed like an explanation would have been helpful or asking if we wanted it a la mode or mixed up like it came. Glad to have a different dessert option in town!
TH
The Truth
I have tried 2 types of pies here - the chocolate merengue and the keylime. Both were very good. The chocolate pie is a dark chocolate and not overly sweet. The key lime pie is mainly sweet with a bit of tartness. I typically enjoy my keylime with a bit more tartness to it, but it was still very good. The crusts and fillings look and taste homemade.
DE
DeAnna Arcement
Underwhelmed. I wanted to love it, but nothing to write home about. We tried the key lime, peach pie, and apple. The key lime was the best of the three; perfectly sweet & tart w/ great crust. The peach & apple were dry and lacked everything that makes fruit pies comforting warm mouth hugs.
BR
Brandy Stephens
Pies are my new favorite and this spot will definitely give you that little piece of sunshine youre looking for on any day. Just the right size, a bevy of delightful flavors, and the people are uber helpful. Be sure to try the Apple Pie Brittle while youre at the register too!
WH
Whitney Risher
The pies in this shop are to die for. Best pie shop Ive been too. They have free samples if you just cant decide on one of their many flavors. Their best pies are cherry and I-40. They have real southern pies just like Grandma used to make. Great service and amazing pie.
DI
Diane Alexander
I had the chess buttermilk pie and it was so-o-o-o-o delicious. I will definitely have to stay in the gym, because I am a chocladdict and must try the chocolate pie! My son loves apple, so it will be a mom-son day out to enjoy these treasures!!! Thanks!!!
MA
Maki Moore
I tried a coconut cream pie. The crust and coconut custard were great. If you buy four of small pies, there will be a little bit of discount. The reason why its not five stars is because its too sweet for me. It will be just sweet for local people though.
AB
Abby Banks
You know a pie is dayum good when you crave it while in another pastry shop. Uh yeah, that really happened! I have no other words, Im on the way. P.S. the buttermilk pie is my favorite, its a must try! Ask for samples if youre undecided.
SI
Siobhan Coman
They catered my wedding in February and did the most fabulous job! We did four flavors of mini pies (apple, I-40, strawberry chocolate, and smores) and they were beautiful and DELICIOUS! Our guests still talk about them!
ME
Megan Walls
We visited buttermilk sky pie shop a few weeks ago. The staff was so friendly and helpful. We couldnt pick just one piece so we left with 3 and cookies. It was well worth the trip and we will be back!!!
RO
Ron Sogueco
Great service, even better pies! Had the chocolate meringue served cloud 9 style, thats the pie mixed in with the ice cream. It was phenomenal. Have it with their Brazilian coffee, great combo.
CA
Cary Goldstein
The pies are spectacular especially the chic chess one! You gotta try these- and that is coming from a dentist no doubt! 4 out of 5 dentists recommend eating these pies! Cary Goldstein, DMD
YA
Yanelin Petersen
There is a lady there who is rude other than that the pie is great. Remember that is not only about the food that this places get a great rating but it is also about the customer service.
BR
Bridget Cunningham
Omg I got 4 different pies, strawberry, pecan, lemon and 2 peanut butter. Im in love with these pies and the customer service tops most. Very professional and the pies are to die for.
PO
Portia Cue
My partner and I are complete Foodies. And we both agree that this pie, hands down, is one of the best pies weve ever had. Especially the apple pie. And the lemon is fantastic!
JA
Jayivey Thrasher
I love pie. They have a lot of good pies. Esp the buttermilk pie. The locations are so far from my house. I feel like the crust could be a little better. But so good
CA
Carenda Lewis
I have been to this place 3 or 4 times and each time I bought 2 personal pies. The staff was friendly and welcoming. Looking forward to my next visit.
LA
Lauren Jones
Preferred Place for Pie ! Apple is my favorite, followed by their Peach Pie. The Coconut and Pecan Pies are tasty but very sweet; try with coffee.
PE
Pedro Ponchio
Incredible pies, specially the apple one. Make sure to serve hot with some vanilla ice cream. Very friendly staff.
RA
raymond rivera
Pies are awesome!! Great customer service! Please come out to support this local business. All pies are great!!
VA
Valentina Gomez Machado
Amazing pies! LOVE the lime ones and the coconut is to die for as well! Cute store. Cute presentation!
DA
Daniel Bullock
I would highly recommend the apple pie! Looking forward to trying an ice cream pie next! Thanks Andrea!
BA
Bahar Mirzai
Very yummy pies! And owner is so sweet and personable. Definitely coming back!
CO
Cornelius Coachman
Very good pies. Just wish they had more flavors. They run out quickly.
JE
Jeffery Durden
Their pies are delicious! Friendly service. The coffee is wonderful.
KI
Kimm Brown
So delish! I had the chewy chocolate chip cloud 9! Go get one!!!!!
PE
Pete Whittingslow
Pies are DELICIOUS! They do a mix with ice cream that is the best
JA
Jaysin Berry
Wife got me an Apple Pie from here... #AhhhhhhMazing!!!
NE
NEGRO MANA
This pies are delicious...Will recommend to everyone.
HE
Heather Gill
Some of the best pies I have ever had!!
RY
Ryan Bucki
The apple and pecan pies were amazing.
SO
Solomon Seaborn
Apple & Pecan pie is literally life.
A.
A. Dawit
Some of the best coconut pie!!
ES
Esther Hwang
Their I 40 pies are amazing!
RY
Ryan Erwin
I love pie!
