Rolling Pin By the Bay - Bakery
| Address: | 184 W Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-647-5112 |
| Site: | rollingpinbakery.com |
| Rating: | 4.3 |
| Working: | 6AM–7PM 6AM–7PM 6AM–7PM 6AM–7PM 6AM–7PM 6AM–7PM 6AM–5PM |
Location
Photos 17
Reviews 17
AM
Amy Lieberman
Our wedding cake looked and tasted wonderful and was delivered with zero stress. We wish Rolling Pin would be a bit clearer on their website about their pricing and which cakes are and are not included (complimentary tastings for weddings would also be nice!). We also wish that they had color options. It’s absolutely amazing that they can match whatever color you want, and I’m sure that people who care more about color themes really appreciate it, but at that point in the planning, we just wanted to be able to say “purply blue” and trust them to do it, without having to find and send a swatch. All that being said, the cake was a hit and everyone at Rolling Pin was very nice over email. It was also great that they were the house vendor for our wedding venue, it made things run very smoothly.
LA
Laura Balsam
The Rolling Pin Bakery created our wedding cake. I have spoken to them over the phone, through email and in person. All experiences were excellent. We were able to do a cake testing in the comfort of our own home, instead of being forced to make an on the spot decision. The design selection process was simple and easy. They provide many beautiful options and special ways to customize, such as using ribbon as accents. The cake was absolutely delicious.
JE
Jennifer Knobloch
I stopped in to sample some of their offerings. The staff was friendly, patient, and helpful as I picked out my items. The small lemon meringue pie and the cherry turnover were delicious and not ridiculously priced. Lovely place; comfy chairs available near the front windows and small tables for dine in patrons.
ZH
Zhao Jenny
I opened the store and saw young and fresh face, how nice to see Mr. Drew Robbins and the girl Aimee working hard there ☺️ !good to see young fellow work on their own . Nice to both of You
K
K VV
Super rude staff! I came in around 7: 03 I did not know they close at 7 , and the cashier was super rude to me she could have said "Im sorry we are close", never coming back again.
MA
Marceil Schmitt
Rolling Pin is a wonderful bakery, everything is always delicious, beautiful and fresh. The staff is pleasant and accommodating. Overall great experience.
SA
Samantha Sigelakis-Minski
Extremely good pastries and bread, and extremely affordable. My only complaint is how busy they get given that they arent that large of a place.
PH
Philip Mazzullo
Ive been stopping by for an espresso and some scones lately and always leave satisfied. The staff is friendly and the service is quick.
ED
Eddie Yates
Great cakes, pastries, donuts etc...drive from 12 miles away to enjoy their stuff. Blueberry turnovers are off the hook!!
CH
Christina Hickey
Their assortment of treats is so fresh and extensive. I am never disappointed!
MI
Michael Wiplich
Great cakes, pastries and scones. Great service by very nice people.
MA
Margaret Trusch
Italian Tri Color Cookie cake with chocolate ganache was AMAZING!!!
TI
Tim Unalp
Average bakery, not dissappointing but not great
TI
TIM MURPHY
Very freash. And the coffee is awsome
BK
BK HVAC
Good place for coffee and a pastry
MA
Markos Vidalon
Loved the birthday cake!!!!!!
HA
Hassan Maynard
The Fruit Tart is great!
