Old Ice House Tavern
| Address: | 1550 Walnut St, New Castle, IN 47362, USA |
| Phone: | +1 765-529-9990 |
| Rating: | 4.8 |
| Working: | Open 24 hours Open 24 hours Open 24 hours Open 24 hours Open 24 hours Open 24 hours Open 24 hours |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 25
CO
Colin Sanberg
Great local bar. Service is always very good. The food is the big draw. Typical "bar food," with the steakburger being the standout item on the menu. Cooked fresh to order, great flavor, and all the fixins. As a bar, good drinks at decent prices. Good local atmosphere, with a loyal contingent of regular patrons.
MA
Marsh Supply
History the history of this place is unreal. Ownership is great. Like family in there. Great customer service great steak sandwiches and food feel right at home
A
A TAXI
Old Mom & Pop vibe with option of newer technology & your served by great workers who will make you great food to top it off!!!
JE
Jeff Wilson
Jimmy is a master bar tender always a good time good food good friends and the coldest beer in Henry county.
ST
Steve Sexton
The Steakburger and the staff are GREAT and the beer is COLD, but dont go is you dont want cigarette smoke.
JO
John Lodge
Best syeak and pepperjack cheese sandwich in town. Chase with a beer and its close to heaven
HE
Helene Donoghue
Great authentic dive bar. Good food. Friendly staff. Holds events often. Highly recommend.
DE
Deepankur Mehta
Laid back,old school bar with carryout famous for there steak burger & hot ham & cheese.
BR
Breanna The Youtuber
They have a good steak sandwich and the people are very kind go there you will like it.
JA
James Johnson
Best steak sandwich in USA.......Ive been every state its best bar handsdown......
CH
Chris Wilkey
Best Steak Sandwich in town. Great people who make it feel like family.
JA
James Emmons
Best steak sandwich around. Coldest beer in town. Mmmm steak and beer.
ST
Stacy West
Great food, Sun King Cream Ale on draft, nd very nice people!!
WI
wildcardjoker
Jane a hottie and great steak sandwich . Miss cousin Mike
EU
Eugene Brandt
Good place to hang out with friends play some pool
NI
Nicole Lunceford
Love stopping here before all my AA meetings!
AN
anthony smith
good drinks great steak sandwich good service
CO
Corey Ward
Cool people and down--to-earth atmosphere.
AN
Angela Duvall
Best steak sandwich in Indiana!
CH
Christina Winters
Love the food and the service
CH
Chad Weaver
Best hole in the wall ever
BR
Brandon Powers
Great place Great food
TE
Teena Muma
Great steak sandwiches
KE
Keith Mcgoldrick
Coldest beer anywhere
TO
Tom Cooper
Awesome food
