Hickory Hills Barbecue
| Address: | 16021 US-31, Edinburgh, IN 46124, USA |
| Phone: | +1 812-526-5280 |
| Rating: | 4.9 |
| Working: | Closed 11AM–8PM 11AM–8PM 11AM–8PM 11AM–8PM 11AM–8PM Closed |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 34
JO
Joan Lucas
Arrived 20 minutes before closing and we were greeted with "were out of everything except the pulled pork and pulled chicken", which I was disappointed about. Im not a fan of either but they were so nice and accommodating. We both got the pulled pork. A quarter pound pulled pork sandwich is under $4.00! It was delicious. I loved the self serve garlicky dill pickles and their homemade cole slaw was awesome. I would love to see other homemade sides like a mac n cheese or macaroni salad. My husband and I ate huge pulled pork sandwiches, coleslaw and drinks for $10. I am planning a trip back ar the end of the month and will call to preorder some ribs and rib tips!
LI
Lisa P
Sooo Good!!! Loved it! Tender juicy meat with lots of Hickory taste. I love BBQ sauce and I always use plenty...but this meats hickory flavor was so good I had to eat most of it without sauce. We tried their baked beans, Cole slaw and tater salad... Everything was great... Great prices and A very friendly staff. Will definitely stop here again.
AA
Aaron York
This is the place to go for smoked meats. Food is excellent and the staff is hospitable. The establishment features a quaint and simple dining room. Some of the best barbeque Ive had in sometime. Pulled pork sandwich was tender and juicy with note fat in the meat. Definetly would eat again
BI
Bidisha Saha
This place is great for Bbq ribs, pulled pork, brisket. Our famiy from Kansas liked the food more than they like the Kansas bbq... so I am positive its the real deal. I would recommend it to anyone. I never forget to order a good bbq dinner from here before they close for winter.
DA
davis brewer
The Troops love this Shack . Fast service and epic mucho sauces to choose from . Why pay high on post club prices for less portions . Hickroy Hills is not skimpy or wimpy with their portions , They should charge more , But I am no telling . A must go to when at Camp Atterbury .
QU
Quientin Anderson
Fantastic BBQ. I never leave reviews, but had to for this place. We were able to get a small sample before deciding and quickly knew we were in the right place. You could taste the smoke in the meat. Good price for the amount of meat. This is what you hope for in a BBQ dive.
LA
Laurie Rue
I was in on Saturday. It was absolutely the BEST brisket Ive ever had. I also got a pulled pork sandwich. Both sauces are delicious. I like to mix mine. The smoked baked beans were good but the coleslaw was extra good! Ill be back to try the rib tips soon!
TO
Todd Wolfe
Good food and an outdoor shaded dining area are the highlight of this no frills bbq joint. I had the pulled pork sandwich and a fountain drinks for around $10. While this big sandwich does not come with any sides, you do get all-you-can-eat pickles.
JE
Jeremy Downey
In town while on Hot Rod Power Tour, and stopped in for supper. While the menu was limited (end of the day, totally understand), the food was fantastic. I had the pork nachos and my dad had the Boss Hog. We thoroughly enjoyed it.
LA
Larry Arreguin
If your a BBQ fan, you cant go wrong with Hickory Hills. In fact, Im sure you be pleasantly surprised you stopped! Fall off the bone ribs, brisket and sides that are made daily will impress the pickiest conisiouer.
A
A Private User
Love this bbq. I stop by at least once every week or so to pick up dinner. Love the pulled pork and the coleslaw is the best and the baked beans are so good. Love this place. Im just lucky to get to live so close
A
A Private User
wife and I both enjoyed the pulled pork sandwich. Ordered a beef brisket, was too stuffed to think about it. Pulled off a bit of meat from it, and it was delicious. Cole slaw was excellent too. Ill be back.
CH
Chris Brinkman
I have been stopping in here since back when I was in the Army. If Im nearby, Im swinging in for a bite. The food is amazing. Prices are good as well. $8 out the door for an amazing beef brisket sandwich.
TI
Tim Blackwell
Im Tim Blackwell the owner of Hickory Hills BBQ, just want every one to know that were are seasonal - closed January and February REOPEN MARCH 3RD 2015 thanks for the support and hope to see you soon.
BE
Ben Zeigler
Great local barbecue, has a lunch rush but otherwise laid back. Their daily specials should always be your first choice, just make sure you get there before they run out. Meat by the pound to go!
DA
David Barker
We ordered take out. I got the "Boss Hog" sandwich and cole slaw. After eating that sandwich, I told my wife I never wanted another sandwich from any other place, ever. Absolutely fantastic.
FR
Fred Head
Fall off the bones ribs. Great brisket and pulled pork. A real rib joint with the meat done right. Sides are good too. Funky rib joint facilities. Do NOT wear a tie, blue jeans and sneakers.
TE
terri mcfetridge
Absolutely love this place. The pulled pork is delicious and I love the pork nachos. I keep wanting to try the brisket but the pork is so good I just keep ordering it. One of these days...
DE
Deborah Potts
9/10/14 ate dinner with friends. Had the Po Boy pulled pork sandwich. Very good food and they give you lots. The place could do for a little dusting in the dining area though.
JU
Julie Pence
Awesome awesome awesome BBQ! Stopped in with less than an hour to close and they were still friendly- and they had nearly everything on the menu! Thank you guys so much!
A
A Private User
I was in there on 5/5/12. They have the best fall off the bone ribs for miles around. If you like Brisket get there early because they sell out. James from Indy...
KE
Ken Reiley
Small, traditional BBQ restaurant. Good prices and good food. Close to Camp Atterburry and right off the highway. The "Boss Hog" was delicious.
A
A Private User
If you are heading from Indianapolis to Louisville, stop here for lunch dinner. Had the huge pulled pork sandwich and Cajun slaw. Very good!
GL
Gloria Taylor
Great BBQ, great baked beans, great potato salad (just like my Mom used to make). Great, great, great!!! Come @ least 2-3 times a month.
MA
Matthew Schaefer
Tasty BBQ, fast and ready. Towards the end of the evening, they ran out of several mains and sides, but the food was still fantastic.
A
A Private User
Excellent pulled pork. Would be 5 stars but they close during winter months! Took my girlfriend there and one sandwich hooked her.
AN
Andres Campos
I love this place. People said City BBQ is better but its more expensive and not enough meat on the bone than hickory hills BBQ.
ME
Megan Morris
7 STARS!! Best BBQ ever! Huge portions. Very good smoked flavor. Sauces and sides excellent. I could eat here every day!
DO
Douglas Cassetty
Pulled Pork, Chicken and sides to go with it. Eat in, outside or take a pound home. Very busy 11:am to 2:pm 4:pm to close.
JE
Jennifer Arthur
We love going to this place to get our BBQ. My son dont go anywhere else. Love their sauces & pulled pork.
CO
Cody Thompson
Food was outstanding and awesome service. Definitely tops my list for barbecue places in the region.
RE
Regan McDole
Best bar-b-q I have had in a very long time. Smoked chicken special on Tuesday is unbelievable.
JO
Joel King
This food will make you want to slap your momma because she failed to ever cook this good.
KA
Kathy Engert
Next time we are in the area we will definitely stop. Wish we would have found you sooner
