Sorrento Pizza & Restaurant

54 N Middletown Rd, Pearl River, NY 10965, USA

Address:	54 N Middletown Rd, Pearl River, NY 10965, USA
Phone:	+1 845-735-0850
Rating:	4.5
Working:	11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM

Location

Photos 23

Reviews 23

Brett Senzer

This is not so much a review of the food but a review of the people. I will preface this by saying the pizza was the best we ever had. The crust was perfect, seasoned to taste, and just a very enjoyable experience. Now, the real purpose of this review. My wife, myself, and a friend have been bringing my brother-in-law, Richard there for about 15 years. Richard lived in a group home for the mentally retarded and whenever we came to see him he always looked forwarded to going to Sorrentos for pizza. We loved taking him there too. We already discussed the pizza, now we will discuss the people. They knew Richard and his situation and they treated Richie with respect and kindness. I think he liked going there because he felt at home. Everyone smiled, everyone talked to him and he was cared about, not as a customer, but as a fellow human being. He was just a guy that liked good pizza and occasionally some very tasty meat balls. So, to the 2 gentleman behind the counter, the waiter that was an absolute gem, my wife and I thank you. The hour or so you gave Richard about once a month will never be forgotten by us. Richard passed away on Tuesday, 12/22/2015. So when you are there enjoying a slice of their pizza think about Richie for a minute and realize, not only are you eating great pizza but it being made and served by some very special people. Thank you very much for your caring and kindness.

Chris Filippone

LITERALLY (& not when people say literally, but mean figuratively) the best pizza I have ever eaten! They have plenty of other fantastic dishes other than pizza, too! Their soups are fantastic, calzones are great, and their sicilian is just as good. I dont mention their desserts, because I almost never get dessert. Anywhere I eat. Even home. So I cant speak to those. Ive heard that theyre pretty good though! I also just wanted to say that I actually created/activated this google plus account, just so I could rate them & help get the word out! These guys know how to make a person (and their stomach) happy!

A Private User

First of all the Pizza is BLAND and BORING. You have to put something on it to make it taste like anything decent. I ordered a Sausage and Pepper Hero, and I got stuff that was watery, mushy, like it had been reheated 10 times and stewed in a pot with a galloon of water. I like CRISP sausage that was pan fried and FRESH vegetables. This place is nasty, and obviously a front, stay away if you are looking for decent food. BLAH!

A Private User

Aside from the terrible decor, and space, this is a good restaurant. I ordered the Pepperoni Sicilian Pizza, and for a dessert, Vanilla Gelato. For starters, the pizza has a lot of pepperoni, but the pepperonis are like the size of a babys big toe. The gelato is fresh and tasty, how gelato should be. Its a fun place to spend a weeknight, or even a weekend.

Joe Hiltabidel

Great atmosphere, great fresh pizza! I was in town only three days and wish I could have eaten here every single day but my company was providing lunch on the other two days. Damn, this is just good pizza, man. Many varieties, very friendly staff, obviously a big local group of fans who were known by first name. Loved it!

Stephen Kaplan

A delightfully charming restaurant / pizza place that is filled with local families and friendly faces. Children frequently come with their parents. The staff is kind, welcoming, easy going and accommodating. The pace is medium to the slow end, and we never feel rushed.

Rick Galente

Salmon was amazing. The guy at the counter knew i was looking for that feugo food and pointed me in the right direction. And great service from everyone including the cute waitress that brought out our food.

LCD PLASMA INSTALLATION

I used to live in rivervale nj and came here for pizza. Always good. Wished I lived closer but live an hr away now. Any chance I am nearby I stop in for a slice

Scott Gruber

Great pizza. Nice crispy crust, robust sauce and the folks working there are super friendly. Its not close to where I live but its worth the trip!

Erik Harris

This place was a little hard to find, but SO worth it! Everything was delicious, and authentic Italian.

james harvilik

The beat eggplant parmigiana sandwich,they only use olive oil in their dishes

Victor Souza

Best pizza outside of the city. Great place for lunch

Daly Carpet Cleaning

One of our favorites On my was now to pick up a pie

James Casey

Pizza is much better then the others in town