Original Italian Pizza & Restaurant
| Address: | 1 Main St, Garnerville, NY 10923, USA |
| Phone: | +1 845-429-4862 |
| Site: | oiprestaurant.com |
| Rating: | 4 |
| Working: | 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 11AM–9PM |
Location
Photos 21
Reviews 27
AN
Anelyse Rodriguez
Great food, BUT if you want COLD FOOD COLD PIZZA FOR YOUR KIDS THEN CALL THIS PLACE, I WAITED 1HR 29MINS BEFORE MY FOOD ARRIVED. AFTER BEING TOLD IT WOULD BE 45MINS MAX. I CALLED BACK TWICE WHILE I WAITED AND BOTH TIMES WAS TOLD FOOD HAD LEFT 20MINS AGO, THEN GET A CALL FROM DRIVER TELLING ME HE NEEDS AN ADDITION 10MINS WHEN FOOD ARRIVED WINGS AND GARLIC KNOTS WHERE COLD ENOUGH TO BE IN SOMEONES DRINK, I ENDED UP MAKING MAC N CHEESE FOR THE KIDS. THANKS ALOT ORIGINALS AND TRUST ME THIS ISNT THE FIRST TIME JUST THE LAST TIME. SINCERLY YOURS PISSED OFF 5 YEAR LONG CUSTOMER
A
A Private User
Since moving into Stony Point in 2006, I have been unable to find decent pizza, that is until now. This place has pizza that is actually better than New City Pizza, which was the standard I used to judge pizza by and grew up eating, but no more. I can now order a great pizza without having to drive all the way to my old neighborhood to get it. So, for all the residents in the area who have been suffering with what other places have called pizza, swing by for the real thing at last. And for all you wanna be pizza places, order one and see how pizza is supposed to tase.
JP
Jp
Ordered a large pepperoni pizza and garlic knots for delivery. When the order arrived in 40 minutes, the pizza was already cold. It was sliced very sloppily and the pepperonis were not baked into the cheese. They clearly took an old plain pizza and poorly reheated it with pepperonis on top. This place used to make great fresh pizza but just sent us leftover garbage. We ordered at 7:25 on a Saturday, I wonder how many other poor people were sent cold pizzas tonight... Needless to say but I will not be re-ordering from OIP.
DO
Dominick DAlisera
Placed order over phone. Asked girl if they had buffalo chicken COLD CUTS. She said "Yes". I then ordered a hero with cheese, a salad and calamari. Came home to find Buffalo chicken breast hot sandwich. Calamari was so well done it was hard. Called on phone to complain and was told they dont have cold cuts. I told the kid that the girl said they did when I placed order. Also when i went to pick it up, i waited over 25 minutes. NEVER AGAIN.
A
A Private User
I was charged with picking up (not ordering, but just picking up) the pizzas from Best Cousin. There were about 6 pizzas, but all of them were very dry, and the crust resembled a dense saltine cracker. They reminded me of baking a frozen pizza too long. We had about 20 people at the party and only 5-6 slices were actually consumed, the rest went into the trash.
KO
KoM NY
These guys are the best! Its all about the "Heather Slices/Pies" <~~~ Vodka Sauce,Fresh Mozzarella,Basil = 1 of the best pizza youll ever taste! Hot wings and Grandma slices are fantastic! Staff are new,young guys that are great people... I highly recommend this Pizza spot ..top 3 in Rockland hands down!
AD
Adam N
This is my favorite place for pizza in the area. There grandmas slices blew me away. Not sure what it is about the dough but its amazing. And their garlic knots are the best I ever had. Not to hard and chewy and they had tons of flavor. Most other places they are either to bland and/or to tough to chew.
OK
ok
This pizzeria is close to me and I go there because it is convenient. That said every once in while I score fresh slice and it is amazing. But the main reason I would recommend this place is friendly people. If they are not to busy they will strike up conversation and share little of their life.
AN
anna smith
I ordered from this place before and the food was amazing, I even recommend friends to it but today I ordered a salad and it was awful other than the fact that the chicken and lettuce was fresh the salad dressing tasted awful I hard to piss and wash my mouth immediately.
BR
Branden Williams
Great food great place called for a deliver at 3:20 and "Chris" said there is a 15 dollar minimum I live 2 min down the road from them and order at least 2 to 3 times a week !! Not anymore "Chris"
AL
Alwin Kuruvilla
One of the best pizza places Ive been to. Love their Buffalo Chicken and Chicken Bacon Ranch pizzas. Had them create a few pizzas for me as well which came out delicious.
CA
Cafe Elienne
I go their almost everyday the pizza is delicious. the people there are really nice. the only thing is its really small but overall everything is perfect
MI
Michelle Hintzsche
Friendly service, good pizza, free delivery above average hot sandwiches! The Milano panini is really good but great on a roll with honey mustard!!!
JO
john lafalgio
Clean, friendly staff, fair priced. Amazing food. Definitely try the wings. They are meaty! Very nice owner.
MI
Michael Peters
Try their grandmas pizza or chicken bacon ranch its amazing
GI
Gilbert Louis
Good pizza, friendly staff what more could yout ask for.
IM
Iman Sain
Great food, and wonderful service. Great prices too!
A
A Private User
Not the best pizza I ever tasted but it was okay
A
A Private User
Eggplant tasted commercial but pizza is amazing.
NE
Nea Amaidan
always the best.. super fast and professional
TI
Tim Tuckey
Great food good service never had a problem
MI
Miranda Kakoullis Dominguez
Rude workers, but good pizza.
GE
Genry Lopez
Very Good Nice People
DE
Denis D
perfect!!!
CR
Cruz Roman
Great pizza
PH
Phil Cipollina
Good menu.
MA
Maureen Murray
AMAZING
