Atlantic Pizzeria & Restaurant

Reviews 7

TI

Tiesha Doyle

I came to Atlantic Pizzeria to celebrate a buddy of mines birthday because it was his favorite pizzeria. Being a musician, there is nothing i enjoy and appreciate more than having music play in a restaurant. I am not talking about music blasting louder than it does in a club, but music playing softly in the background so that you dont have to listen to another tables conversation. Atlantic Pizzeria plays classy Blues and Jazz music which goes perfect with their decor. They have photographs and a mural painted on the wall that is museum quality. Absolutely incredible. As soon as I walked in, I told my friend that this has to be the coolest pizzeria I have ever seen. He told me to wait until I tried the pizza... The staff accommodated all 11 of us, putting some tables together. We went to order a bunch of small bottles of coke and they recommended saving a few dollars and just getting 2 liters as we needed them which i thought was very nice of them to do, most places would rather make the extra money instead of helping the customer do the more logical thing. When our pies came out, I felt like a kid in a candy store. We ordered a Cheese Pie, a Layered Eggplant Pie, and a Grandma Pie. I am still trying to decide on my favorite...thats how good they all were. The cheese pie was the best I have ever tasted. It wasnt greasy and they do something to their crust to give it the perfect amount of crispiness. The Eggplant pie was better than I expected. Three layered of delicious eggplant with marinara sauce in between each layer then dolloped with ricotta cheese on top. It was phenomenal. The grandma pie we got more for the ladies with us, but we ended up having to order an extra Grandma pie because everyone enjoyed it so much. I was very impressed with this Bluesy Pizzeria. I have never been anywhere quite like it. I will definitely be back.

---

VI

Viola Harned

My husband and I were looking for somewhere different to go out to eat. We went to drop off some dry cleaning then grabbed a menu from the Pizzeria next door. As I read down their appetizers and entrees, my mouth started to water. We decided to get dinner at Atlantic Pizzeria. We ordered mussels marinara and crisp calamari as apps and Veal Calabrese and Chicken Ala Nicole for entrees. We went to order a salad to share but the waitress informed us that our meals will each come with a small salad. When the appetizers came out, we quickly dove right in. The calamari was on point. Crisped to perfection and the marinara sauce had the perfect amount of heat for me. My wife asked if they had some sauce that wasnt as spicy and the waitress quickly brought out some plain marinara for her which she absolutely loved. The mussels were outrageous. I was getting ready to order another plate of them when our entrees were brought out. The plates were huge! Well worth the price of the meals. The veal was tender and the chicken was delicious. My wife and I were very impressed and very happy with our meal. We now return to Atlantic Pizzeria as often as possible. The food is great, the prices are reasonable, and the service is excellent.

---

VI

vinyl bay

To all Italian Food lovers, my name is Kith and I love Italian food especially Pizza and Pizzerias I truly believe that small mamas and papas Italian food places are heart of True Italian Cooking. I have been to hundreds of places and I have seen good and bad places but I need to share this place with you .. Atlantic Pizzeria located on Atlantic avenue in Freeport is like taking a step back in time like how Pizzerias in Brooklyn, Manhattan and the Bronx use to look like. I never seen a counter display like this pizzeria.From 6 different stuffed garlic nut to about 7 to 8 different Rice balls to stuff Mushrooms, Peppers, Zucchini and Eggplant . The amount of specialty pizza and rolls they had was overwhelming, I had a 3 layer Eggplant slice and sausage roll the first thing I noticed was how crispy the crust was then how good the sauce tasted. I know I have found my new pizza place. I cant wait to come back and try something else.If you are in the neighborhood you should check this Pizzeria out, I forgot to mention how cool the place looks like and the great music they play. You should definitely check this place out.

---

HO

Horselo285

My family and I have been coming to this pizza place for years. Its always been a bit overpriced, but the food was decent and its right nearby us, so it was worth it...UNTIL today. It turns out there is NO customer service. Owner is very rude. I was quoted a price on the phone for pineapple topping and then charged a different price. Owner basically accused me of lying that I was quoted that price and was very rude. Overpriced in general anyway but was sort of worth it until now. Now I do not recommend. Also doesnt abide by discounts! Sign in door says $12.59 (or similar) for large pie on Sundays. Wanted to charge me $23 because I added pineapple to it. In the end he charged me $18 which I accepted because I needed to just get away from that rude man. $18 for a Sunday special pizza with added pineapple? And he wanted to charge me more? Screw that! Dont go here! NO CUSTOMER LOYALTY, NO CUSTOMER SERVICE and a RUDE owner. Will NEVER come here again.

---

KE

Kenneth Pena

I have always loved Atlantic Pizzerias pizza and garlic knots but now I have a new obsession. They make these Stuffed Knots that are filled with delicious things...like cheese, pepperoni, buffalo sauce, pesto sauce, and roasted peppers. I cant even explain how yummy they are. The Roasted Pepper ones are my favorite. They have the right amount of mozzarella cheese mixed with roasted peppers, it is just delicious. The stuffed knots are served with a cup of their homemade marinara sauce which is out of this world. I always ask for extra sauce and find myself scraping the cup clean because it is just so good. I highly recommend getting some of their Stuffed Knots. I have gotten all of my friends to try and they love them too.

---

ES

Estella Londono

Been going to this restaurant for the first time and the food was fine but the is very rude and personel cursing at me in front of my kids and disrespecting me as a customer. My son and I was talking on the phone with my other son then the owner send the waitress to turn off the speaker because it was bothering the other customer, but there were no other customers around just my son and I in the restaurant. Then he tried to overcharged me for the food that cost $10.95 ea., no drinks and he charged $40.15 and I showed him the menu that the plate cost 10.95 ea. and he said unpleasant words to me so i agree to the bill, and I left because i was feeling uncomfortable with him.

---

JA

Jane Falcone

moved to freeport a year ago. would go to different pizzerias to try different pastas knowing i would be ordering for the holidays. atlantic was my pick. you order something and say you will pick it up at 2, go in become 2 its not ready, which means to me its not sitting there. the young women who works there is a joy, i tell her when im picking it up and when im serving it, she talks to the chef and tells me the best way to heat it so it doesnt get dried out. prices to me are fine.

---

---