Pizza Supreme
| Address: | 678 Stewart Ave, Garden City, NY 11530, USA |
| Phone: | +1 516-228-4300 |
| Site: | pizzasupremeinc.com |
| Rating: | 4.4 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 12–8PM |
Location
Photos 29
Reviews 14
JA
Jacob Gonzalez
High School cafeteria pizza taste better than this. If you want to eat the most depressing pizza in the world then this is the place for you. The interior looks boring and uninspiring. How hard is to hang a few pictures or colorful posters? The people working there were not rude but acted more miserable than the pizza. The guy that makes the pizza also handles the dirty money from the cash register without even wearing gloves. Stay away unless you are constipated and need a quick solution.
AN
Andrew Perillo
Going there since I was a child was always the highlight of my day on the rare occasions I got to go. Even coming back from college the first place I go after a long drive from Ohio is this place. The square pizza is the best Ive ever had the pleasure of tasting and the staff are quite friendly and the place is absolutely spotless. I would highly recommend. Love these guys.❤
DA
Dave Hom
20 years ago was the last time I had the "square" pizza here. It was good back then, its still as good today!!! I had started in the 80s eating pizza supreme when they were in the mall across the street and "timeout" video arcade was next door. What a perfect combo...
AN
Ana maria Higueros
Disfrutamos con mi esposo deliciosas pizzas, frescos vegetales, salsa de tomate natural y tostaditas.
CA
Carmine M
The staff are good and the place is clean. The Sicilian Slice is very good, but very small. The regular slice could be very good but sometimes they are very salty. It all depends on who makes it because sometimes its excellent.
A
A Private User
Pizza around the garden city area is pretty bad however supreme pizza provides fresh and delicous pizza. I recommend everyone to try it, you wont be disappointed.
RO
Robert Spink
Great pizza. I always stop in when I am in the area. The "square" slices are great. Smaller than an average "Sicilian" slice but no compromise in quality.
LE
Leonard R. Ticsay
My Dad used to take me to Roosevelt Field for square slices when I was a kid. Supreme is in a new location, but the pizza is still as good as I remember.
SU
Susan Cushman
I actually really like the square pie & Pizza Supremes homemade sauce. Try the spaghetti or eggplant parm sometime! :)
FA
Fabiola Landaverde
quick bite ... really good food i just wish they had more choices to pick from but still really good and tasty
JA
Jam Ham
Great service and delicious food. What more can you ask for? Also, you must try their minestrone soup, yum.
RY
Ryan Shapiro
The square slices are the best kept secret in the area. So good, order a pie with a couple of friends!!
KA
Karen Clements
Pizza was good. Not too much bread.
AM
Ammar A.
Delcious Pizza.
