Hometown Cafe
| Address: | 104 E Main St, East Islip, NY 11730, USA |
| Phone: | +1 631-224-2766 |
| Site: | hometowncafeei.com |
| Rating: | 4.6 |
| Working: | Closed 5:30AM–9PM 5:30AM–9PM 5:30AM–9PM 5:30AM–9PM 5:30AM–9PM 7AM–1PM |
Location
Photos 54
Reviews 24
AN
Angela Cooke
Very hometown! It is set back on the lot so much that I have past it almost daily for 3 months and didnt realize it was there. I ran in to try it out on a week day at lunchtime. There is plenty of free parking and upon entering I was greeted and seated right away. The inside is dark and has older wood paneling of some kind on the walls. The tables and chairs are a 1990s style and there are some old plaques hung on the walls. The lighting is also dim so it is not a bright sunny place. There is a flat screen TV hung where everyone could see it but not hear it and there was no closed captions so you could not really tell what was going on. It was a hot day but very comfortably air conditioned. The waitress took my order right away and it took only a few minutes to get my food. I ordered a BLT which came with a large pickle slice, wonderfully fresh, thick cut fries served nice and hot and the BLT on thick sliced toasted White bread. This was made with honest to goodness REAL bacon, not the microwave stuff. It had very thick cut slices of real summertime homegrown tomatoes a d cold, crispy fresh lettuce. My only dislike was that it was slathered in real mayo (which others may love). A great thick fresh sandwich! It was served with an icy cold coke..yummm. One thing they can Improve is the cleaning I would not say it was dirty, but as I picked up the salt & pepper glass shakers I felt as if they had not been run through the dishwasher in a very long time and the same with the ketsup glass bottle. When I left there was a couple pieces of crumpled papers and napkins right by the door. Food A+, cleanliness a C.
JO
John Gerretz
I just moved out to the area and took a Sunday morning drive just exploring Montauk highway. Got Hungry around 8am and found this place on the road with my girlfriend. We sat at the counter because it was busy at the tables (a good sign) and were treated warmly from the second we walked through the door to the signature on the check. Perfect spur of the moment stop on a Sunday morning. All of the staff was very warm, welcoming and professional, particularly the young man at the counter. Were definitely coming back!
JO
Joseph Cappellino
We just found this place! We had dine-in breakfast on the first day, everything was delicious, and the staff was friendly and fast. Then, we had dinner delivered the following day, and, again, everything was delicious.
MI
Michael Jones
The waitress was quite polite and attentive to our needs.The blueberry french toast special was very tasty,and fresh blueberries.Will definitely go back and try more items on the menu!
RO
Robert Flannigan
We use to go for breakfast only. Great breakfast. Now we went twice for dinner. Both times our meals very good. Reasonably priced. Full bar too.
AN
Antonia Worthman
Great breakfast served fast & friendly ! These people know what they r doing ! Never disappointed been going for about 3 years!
EL
Elizabeth M
Good food and fast service. If Im ever in the area again Ill be sure to stop by. Just loved, loved their cheeseburger!
LA
Lacy Bender
Warm and friendly staff and the food is amazing. The home cooked meal you didnt have to stay home for!
LI
Lisa Seminera
This is our go to breakfast spot. Have Never been disappointed. Always consistent.
PA
Pat Lapp
Service was great food was par. Good in a pinch but I wouldnt go out of my way.
MA
Mary Frevola
Good food and wonderful service. Cant wait to come back again.
AN
Anthony Viscuso Jr
WE miss our Sunday breakfast with my brother and his wife.
JI
Jimmy Schiraldi
Enjoyed the food. Good specials. Breakfast lunch dinner.
ED
Edward Ciano
Good food and very nice service. Will be back again
KE
Keith Howard
Atmosphere is cozy and casual. Food is good
MI
Michael Passalacqua
Great beer great people
LO
Louis Rivera
Good all hometown feel
RO
Ron Neill
Awesome breakfast spot.
BK
BK HVAC
burgers were amazing!
AR
Arun Vasudeva
Good breakfast spot.
RO
Robert Reichel
The ifood is. Great
BO
Bob McElroy
Great breakfast.
BR
Bryan Baeza
Foods amazing
LI
Liam Dougherty
BACON !!!!!
