Edgartown Pizza
| Address: | 224 Edgartown Rd, Edgartown, MA 02539, USA |
| Phone: | +1 508-627-7770 |
| Site: | edgartownpizzamenu.com |
| Rating: | 3.6 |
| Working: | 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM 10:30AM–9PM |
Location
Photos 97
Reviews 22
FI
firstrainen
I thought people were being jerks saying they serve frozen pizza. They were not wrong, and it only takes being served to know it. The pizza was borderline burned on top and barely cooked underneath. That is a dead giveaway, a pizza oven is not the proper place for frozen pizza, nor is a pizza parlour. I was tempted to ask for a refund immediately, but we already started on the pie, so I bit the bullet. Thank god I only ordered a cheese pizza and fries. The fries were also frozen shoestring, how do I know because the were hauling frozen food across the diner while we ate. I dont recommend this for anyone. Theres a supermarket up the street a bit and you can buy a better quality frozen pizza there for half the price.
LE
Leigh Bauer
Ordered take out tonight and it was awful. The mozzarella sticks came wrapped in a piece of wax paper and flattened by the sauce they jammed in the tiny container. 6.95 for 6 flat soggy mozzarella stocks. The steak tips were actually thin slices of beef drowned in sauce and the sandwich wasnt any better. Quality has gone way, way down. They used to use actual steak tips and care about the food they sold. Heres hoping they can bring it back to how good it used to be.
OL
Old Oklahoma
Best pizza on the island! Their cheese is some sort of cheddar blend that makes their pizza a unique (and delicious) departure from the other somewhat lackluster pizza restaurants on the island
KE
Kemar Griffiths
Its good for quick lunch or afternoon meal, daily Brazilian lunch specials,pizza,burgers etc, nothing over the top, just your average fast food, GLUTEN FREE meals available
KE
Ken Schoenberg
One of the best family-style restaurants on the Island. We really enjoy their "Brazilian" Dinners. Theyre not only filling, but good tasting and reasonably priced.
LE
Leonard R
Horrible frozen pizza I would probably compare to Elios from the supermarket. At least the place is clean and the staff courteous.
MA
Mason Dill
Edgartown Pizza has the BEST pizza in the WHOLE WORLD!!! I also ordered a Buffalo Chicken sandwich, it was to die for.
JU
Justin Wear
Good pizza that brings back memories of family vacations on the island. Dont eat there, call ahead and take out.
ME
melody sterling
Went for lunch , had the blue cheese burger. It was absolutely delicious. Minimum wait , quiet hang out spot.
BI
Billy M
5 star pizza joint Best Bleu burger. Friendly and courteous staff. Hope to return time and time again.
PH
Phil Shumway
Great pizza shop with nice variety and good food. I look forward to it every time Im on the island
A
A Private User
We loved the pizza and fresh salads. Great inexpensive food on the Vineyard.
BR
Bradford Bell
Got the chicken cesar wrap. Desent size. Price wasnt bad for the location.
MI
Michael Vivenzio
Absolutely disgusting ordered 100$ of take out and threw it in the trash
CH
Chris Savino
Meh.... pizza was just meh. Nice place though.
TH
TheSatelliteCowboy
Had a large pizza with mushroom, it was great!
TH
Thatcher Ulrich
Friendly place serving bad frozen pizza.
AN
Anthony Gilmette
Pizza was good
JO
John T
good pizza!!!
GI
Gil Scott Chapman
Great pizza
AL
al ferland
Good Pizza
BR
Bro With The Fro
best pizza
