Crostini Sandwiches
| Address: | 231 North St, Madison, WI 53704, USA |
| Phone: | +1 608-241-4284 |
| Site: | madisoncrostinisandwiches.com |
| Rating: | 4.6 |
| Working: | 10:30AM–8:30PM 10:30AM–8:30PM 10:30AM–8:30PM 10:30AM–8:30PM 10:30AM–8:30PM 11AM–8:30PM Closed |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 36
JE
Jeffrey Frye
While not perfectly authentic, the chicago-style (little c for a reason!) hot dogs are pretty tasty, and the service was polite and incredibly friendly. Ill be back again very soon Im sure, and Ill be bringing my other fellow former-Chicagoan Madisonites yearning for a decent dog. Crostini, if youre listening--Chicago-style requires a pickle spear (not a gherkin) and copious amounts of mustard. I commend you on including the oft-overlooked sport peppers and celery salt though!
ER
Erin Barry
After a variety of businesses moved in and out of this small building on North St. in a few years, I felt like the location was doomed. Yet, Crostini has been here for more than a few years now, and seems to be doing great, and for good reason! Their extensive menu has something for all palates, and the service is quick and friendly. My go-to, however, has always been the Italian beef sandwich - get it with the spicy peppers, skip the cheese, and make sure its wet!
RO
Rose S
I have only eaten inside a handful of times so naturally when Crostini started to deliver I jumped on the band wagon. When I called in my order I was given polite and prompted service. Although my order took close to an hour to arrive the paninis were warm and delightful. What gave me the need to type this review was the delicious homemade chocolate chip cookies. I did not order them and was surprised by the nostalgia I got from them.
DA
Dave Shapiro
“Good things come in small packages”. Crostini Sandwiches is a small (compact) restaurant that provides excellent food choices. From Paninis to Italian Roast Beef, the food is very tasty and fresh. There is a variety of offerings that matches far larger restaurants. There is a small (10 person) eating area indoors and some tables outside for dining. One of the better choices in Madison.
JO
Jon Karch
Giving it 5 because the food was super good however they gave French instead of garlic bread and didnt include the ordered parm garlic chips. Aint no thing but a chicken wing though. Cant judge a place by one order and the food was extremely good (WI Mac and cheese and Italian paninni). Will definitely order from here again. Peace.
RA
Ranessa Williamson
I didnt know what to expect going into this small sandwich shop but I left extremely impressed with the whole experience. The menu is extensive with a lot of great options but when I heard the owner was from Chicago I knew I had to try the Italian beef and I was so happy I did. It was fantastic!! The service was also great.
CA
Carl Jaske
Sandwich was good. Coffee came out 20 seconds after I noticed it hadnt, they gave me a free cookie to apologise. Unnecessary but cool of them all the same. I have a weakness for paninis. I was asked twice how my food was by the staff even though we were the only ones outside. Outdoor seating is limited, but its a small lot.
DR
Drew Maier
Nothing but the kindest, happiest people at this Chicago style shop, and great food at that. Cant go wrong with anything on the menu, whether youre getting it delivered taking it to go, or stopping in to take a little break (now much easier with their expanded seating) crostinis cant be beat.
SH
Shannon-Mary Obbagy
Its the third time Ive been here, and the food and service has never dissapointed. They have amazing sandwiches, wraps, soups, fries, and lemonade. And an amazing selection of sanwhiches to boot. I havent tried them all, but all the ones i have tried have been amazing.
IA
Ian Pozdol
This store has a perfect ambience as a local neighborhood sandwich shop. There is an adjoined room for more tables to eat with a larger group, but the small window counter and the 3 sidewalk tables are what make this experience special. Great food is a given.
JU
Juliet Darken
Superb gluten free sandwiches and very friendly, excellent service. They even have gluten free desserts. I love the expanded indoor seating. Outdoor seating on a pleasant street. Delivery and catering also available with a ton of options on the menu.
AM
Amber B
Other than mac and cheese this place always dissapoints. Today order lasagna. First forgot it at delivery the it has more spinach than lasagna not impressed with their salad with tomato sauce. The bread always tasted like lead and is dry also.
AV
Avery Craig
I love Crostinis! They have a fresh and original menu, and provide outstanding and friendly service. Im happy there is finally a business in that space that is bound to last :) It has been a great addition to the neighborhood. Thanks guys!
SA
Sarah Jean Hartnell
TURKEY, ARTICHOKE AND SPINACH- Turkey, artichoke hearts, spinach spread and baby Swiss. I wasnt expecting something that sounded so simple to be so amazingly delicious. I just wish it came with chips, pickle spears, or something.
JO
John Springer
Waited over an hour for delivery to have Mayo on a sandwich. Specifically stated just meat n Cheese. They closed at 7pm got it delivered at 7:45 all I get is an answeing machine...Never Again!!
BR
Brittani Baynard
Not only is the food amazing and well priced, but every time I go in there I see nothing but smiles and the staff is super nice and polite! One of the greatest little places to eat in Madison !
ZA
Zach Heise
Delicious little new place that serves a wide variety of Midwest themed foods. The owner constantly gives me free cookies in my delivery! I dont know why but I dont mind a bit!
CH
Chris McRay
The service was terrific and food was incredible at this unassuming hole in the wall! I had a cup of soup, the best ever, and a sandwich. Highly recommended!
RA
Rachel Whaley
What a great place to eat! There is WAY more than just sandwiches and Ill be back to try more. Great food, service and you can eat outside if you wish!
PA
Payton Bender
Absolutely delicious food. An extremely wide menu for such a small restaurant. Friendly and efficient staff. Great place for lunch at a good price
T
T Lo
Great place. Thought it would be tiny but it has a dinning room. Good food and service. Only 4 stars now but could rise to 5 on next visit.
TO
Todd Beecher
Best little gem on the east side of town. Go there and you wont be disappointed, the food is excellent and the dessert is sharing!!
HO
Hollie Laura Johnthompson
Food is delicious! The added dining space is great. The only negative is the ventilation - sometimes it gets a bit smokey inside.
SH
sharon kokkines
Best sandwiches and pasta in Madison. And they deliver too ! Cooked to order so everything is fresh and nice friendly service.
CA
Cali L
I absolutely love this place. Great food and excellent customer service! Best place in Madison to get an Italian beef sandwich.
DO
Doug Dalsing
Everything on the menu is good. Great for carryout of you live nearby. Order, walk in, take your food home.
ER
Erich Moraine
Limp fries cold undercooked grilled cheese, dirty wrappers and spills on the floor. Wont come back.
BE
Benjamin Sculley
Great little shop! Got the Turkey, artichoke panini with potato salad. Super delicious and fresh.
RO
Roman Barut
great sandwiches great service great atmosphere great staff just great Overall: its pretty good
AM
amy follett
Freshly prepared, huge variety, sweet people and oh my my deliciously prepared food for you!
AL
Allen Wohlfeil
Great place for lunch! Homemade soups and the best Paninis, Pastas and breakfast sandwiches!
RO
Roderick Birrenkott
Friendly staff, lots of options depending upon what youre hungry for and high quality food.
KA
Katherine Essenburg
SO good! Food arrived hot, fresh and especially tasty. Will definitely order again!
GR
Grant H
Great service, great food. Make sure to order the works with your Chicago dog.
JO
Jorge Ramirez
The food was so amazing and the people who attended me were so quick and polite
DE
Dennis Brennan
i eat there 2 a month and i love it they delv promptly food is always good
