Athenian Diner
| Address: | 1426 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT 06515, USA |
| Phone: | +1 203-397-1556 |
| Site: | athenian-diner.com |
| Rating: | 3.6 |
| Working: | 7AM–12AM 7AM–12AM 7AM–12AM 7AM–12AM 7AM–12AM 7AM–12AM 7AM–12AM |
Location
Photos 1
Reviews 46
A
A Private User
My fiance and I both ordered omelettes. The omlettes were skimpy with ingredients and were very overcooked. I ordered one with four very cheap ingredients and was charged $11 for my omelette. I was charged $1.75 per ingredient! Overall, a very disappointing experience. It is hard to mess up breakfast but somehow the Athenian pulled it off. There are many other diners in the area that will provide you with better food for a fraction of the price. Skip the Athenian and keep on driving.
VE
VELMA Williams
My breakfast was very good! My waiter was pleasant and made sure our needs were met. The hostest on the other hand left a lot to be desired... When we came in we asked for a both by the window she tried to place us at one of the tables within. I intern asked for a both near a window she complied but dud not seem to hsppy about. Her body language made that clear. All in all the service was good the food was good. The place is beautiful.
KI
Kimberly LaPointe
I stopped in with my family while traveling through town. The staff was incredibly welcoming and helpful. The food is basic diner style, but is well done. They have a bakery on-site and have a case full of fresh baked goodies. The GIANT chocolate chip cookie was great!
JO
Josh Schwamb
The service is adequate, and so is the food. You dont go into a diner expecting the best food youve ever had, you expect decently good food with a wide selection to choose from. Ive tried this place a few times, and their food falls a bit below that bar for me.
A
A Private User
The dinners we ordered were not worth the $88 we paid. Of course we chose not to leave a tip. The food was not good. Fountain drink refill were free except for seltzer water. I would not recommend this place to anyone. Save your money and spend it elsewhere.
SA
samantha kennedy
Friendly, fast service. Good food, but when I asked if their corned beef hash was made on site or pre-made, waitress said freshly made on site. It really did look like every canned, frozen hash Id ever seen, and my son said it did not taste fresh.
JA
jared simpson
Fish and chips were terrible, fries where terrible, everything under seasoned. Batter was soggy, fries were not crispy or salted properly. salad was fine. coleslaw was dry and gross no acid. late night cravings were not satisfied
AL
Alex Clement
I called ahead Friday night to see what time they closed, the guy on the phone said they start closing at 11:45. I arrived there at 11:25 and the door was locked and no one acknowledged that I was at the door. Very disappointing.
JA
James Hart
The diner isnt necessarily the best breakfast place in Westville, but I cant stand the lines and the wait at some of the places in downtown Westville. The service is always great and the food is good and affordable.
A
A Private User
TERRIBLE. If you have every been to a good diner in NY metro area or on the shore line you will be insulted. How hard is it to make fresh French today instead of frozen sysco garbage?
JO
Johnny King
Ive been coming to the Athenian since 2008, and let me tell you, I love this place. Great food and atmosphere. Were regulars (my wife and I) for a reason.
JU
Judine Nelson
The food was OK but dont get the blue berry muffin its cold even when they toast it. The employees at the front talk about customers that come and go.
KE
Kenneth Karan
Home cooked food away from home. Breakfast, burgers, cakes, and Greek specialties excel here. Always fresh. Great service. Reasonable prices.
AM
amy bresson
This place has horrible wait staff and hires immigrants to work there! The food is ok but everything else is unprofessional!
SE
Seán Bardong
THE BEST PANCAKES TO DATE!!! MY FAVORITES ARE THE BLUEBERRY PANCAKES. SORRY GRANDMA, BUT THEYRE BETTER THAN YOURS
MI
Mike B
They have the most consistent quality and great food that I have been eating for the past 22 years
A
A Private User
Fresh and delicious! Always great service!! The chicken Marsala is my favorite or London Broil!!
KA
Kath Lutz
We eat here at least twice a week. Love the food and staff. One of our favorite places.
BO
Bob Melko
Typical diner fare at a higher than typical price. Especially breakfast.
JO
jorge lopes
Food is good. A little slow in seating us because of Mothers Day
JO
Joe Burnes
Had the souvlaki. No flavor and the driest chicken Ive ever had.
MI
mike Appello
On an off Merritt parkway, good eats, and a full service bar!
CY
Cynthia Decarlo
Food is good. Desserts are home made. Waitstaff attentive.
JA
James Rawlings
Great breakfast and service Only wish they served grits!!
DI
Diana Breeze
Penelope was a wonderful waitress we enjoyed our meal
FR
Frank Ward
Excellent beyond expectations. The very, very best.
WI
Wilson Santana
Clean place loved the food everybodys nice as well
KI
Kimberly A Mintz
Friendly and fast service with reasonable pricing
NA
Nathan Wei
gave the wrong order to us. Over charged us too.
KE
kenneth wallen
Good service, good food and really clean
MI
Mike Irongunz Mosley
Good breakfast! Good bacon cheeseburgers
RE
Rebecca Liss
Good food, large menu, extremely pricey
JE
Jean Clark
Not real Greek food. Really gross.
TH
Thomas Mangieri
Terrible food. Go somewhere else.
TA
Tal R
Decent bacon and egg sandwiches
A
A Private User
Excelent and tastefull food!
E
E Saunders
Many of great meals eaten
CA
Catherine Gootkin
Good food. Nice people.
PH
Philip Fioretti
Good food fast service
CH
Chris Rand
Tasty, affordable food
ST
Stephanie Wilborne
Always just right!!!
DE
Denise Victoria
Some good breakfast
TR
Trish Dolan
Best Diner Food
JO
Jonathan Mulla
good Diner food
SC
Scott McCoy
Excellent!
DA
Dana Carter
Great food
