Four Brothers Pizza
| Address: | 4957 NY-22, Amenia, NY 12501, USA |
| Phone: | +1 845-373-8178 |
| Site: | fourbrotherspizzainn.com |
| Rating: | 3.8 |
| Working: | 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM 10AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 100
Reviews 34
GA
Gail Riley
Ive been enjoying 4 bros for many years. Always had a great meal until today. Ordered the greek salad as always and for a change, I ordered the alla vodka. The lettuce in the salad was old. It was brown and unappetizing to say the least. I mentioned it to the waiter who said it looked bad to him too, as he walked away. No offer to replace it. The alla vodka smelled exactly like beefaroni I ate as a kid, and I ordered it with shrimp. I lifted a forkful of pasta and shrimp and put it in my mouth. They left the tails on the shrimp!! Really?? You couldnt take the tails off of 6 large shrimp??!! I honestly am stunned by my meal and not in a good way. I seriously love the pizza, best anywhere. And, always loved the greek salad. What happened to you? The bagged lettuce has to go! Your cook staff needs to pay attention to details, like taking the tails off the shrimp served in a sauced pasta dish. Youve become complacent with your popularity. Im so disappointed. Youve sold out to convenience and the fast food mentality. What a shame! You used to take pride in serving terrific fresh food. I guess it had to happen, eventually all good things come to an end.
CL
Clemens Wan
Since this place is in the middle of nowhere for me, Ive only been here a hand-full of in the past 8 years when going on the Christmas day Vermont ski trip. Its a tradition to stop by this place on the way up or returning to grab dinner with some antipasta, mozzarella sticks, and a pizza pie. Just last week, we were here completely exhausted from a long ski day, and the smell of brick oven pizza made the whole family wake up. As my friends Dad puts it, this is the best worst thing for you. Even the plain slices taste great without any additions, but it is surely a once-in-a-while treat. Id probably gain too much weight and get clogged arteries - thus is the result of most delicious food. Plus - everything tastes better after hours of driving and skiing. The restaurant itself looks fantastic. The walls are painted to give it an old Roman ruins type of feeling. The lighting makes me feel like everything is yellow-ish tan (which summarizes parts of Italy very well). The staff is attentive and extremely nice - great pizza and even better company. This place will always be a classic and always stay a regular.
HU
Hungry Hippy Gaming
If I could give 0 stars I would I dont know what happened it used to be so good. The last few times Ive gotten food there to go my cheese burger was not cooked it had days old brown lettuce in it, the chicken wrap chicken was hard as a rock, the mozzarella sticks didnt even have cheese inside of them. I kept giving them chances hoping the next time I ordered food it would be better but such a disappointment ever time.
JE
jessica beaumont
Me and my parents decided to try the out side area where you can get a quick bite so we ordered two hot dogs and a cheese burger all with fries and a drink and when she gave me the price I was shocked I went here thinking it would be cheaper but it cost over $30:00 and it might not seem like a lot to some but I thought it would have been cheaper than going inside the restaurant.
A
A Private User
It is a good greek style pizza place that also has a good cesar salad. It has fresh ingredients from around the area such as their cheese and one of a kind home made greek salad dressing that cant be matched anywhere else. The pizza is delicious with a crispy crust and melted chesse that makes me go back for more.
E-
E-Man
4 brothers is a fixture in the mid Hudson valley region. Really good pizza, salads and "Italian" type dishes. Other food, not so much (dont bother with the burgers, fish and chips, fried chicken etc). Good place to go for a decent lunch or dinner.
TI
Tigh Loughhead
The Greek/Italian ambience is kind of bizarre, and I cant tell if its neat or just odd. The restaurant is a very big place, Im good for groups – the food is nothing really special (rather bland).
DI
Diana Parker
Wine is served in an airplane style bottle and the calamari was overcooked . Nice clean place and nice wait staff however. Beware they charge you for club soda.
CH
chris slater
Not good any other time I been it was good service was bad the bbq wrap was over powered by onions and the bbq sauce was soupy not happy with it at all
LA
Laura Stanaway
Waiter was extremely rushed, didnt stay at table to hear complete order. Waited too long to receive check.food was adequate.
KE
Keith Walk
Greeks suck at making pizza. Im sitting in this place right now!!! Go to santos down the road and youll be glad you did.
MA
Matt Z
Service and food were great. Booth table was all sticky on the edge. There were lots of dead bugs on the windowsill.
AL
Alison Mosimann
Finally found a place near us that consistently delivers awesome food! Everything is top notch!
MI
Michael OKeefe
Food isnt as good as the price implies, but it is decent and you can do the drive in next door.
LI
lisa morton
Omg this pizza is heavenly! Large cut toppings, tasty sauce and a beautiful patio to sit on.
PA
Paul Statt
Great Greek salad and free Wi-Fi in a town without cell coverage. Beer and wine limited.
WI
William Carl
Great pizza and a good menu of other great food. Always have had fabulous service
RI
Rich Danise
Stopped on the way home from a day trip. Excellent Food & good service.
BO
Bobbi Colao
Great place! Nice atmosphere! Great staff! They even have a drive-in!
BR
Brian Janesky
Love the place amazing really enjoyed it everybody should take a visit
AD
Adriana Gutierrez
Buen servicio
AR
Arthur Whitcomb
Fun place - old fashioned drive in movie as well.
PA
Pamela Cooper
Best Greek Salad in the world!!!!!!
SA
samantha kennedy
Friendly and prices are just right
TA
Tanmoy Mallick
Good pizza! Long waiting time...
JO
Joy Betonio
Local pizza place for everyone
KE
Kelly Bohlinger
Service was slow food ok
NI
Nicholas Suby
Good food, great Mexicans.
JO
Joseph Bahr
Love this magical place.
LU
Lucy Caban
Good food, great service
BO
Bonnie Brill
Good food, menu lacking
RY
ryan collins
Great people and food
BR
Bryan Oppenheimer
Great food
SA
Savvas Savvopoulos
Tasty food
