Stelton Pizza and Restaurant
| Address: | 1315 Stelton Rd, Piscataway Township, NJ 08854, USA |
| Phone: | +1 732-985-2626 |
| Site: | steltonpizza.com |
| Rating: | 4.1 |
| Working: | 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–10PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 11AM–11PM 12AM–10PM |
Location
Photos 61
Reviews 48
A
A Private User
We spent a pretty penny for 3 dinners there this evening. All 3 were absolutely horrible. I will never again get pasta there. They totally destroyed our pasta! How is it possible to send out pasta dishes not knowing you mutilated the main part of the dish?? The alfredo dish had shrimp and was 14.50!! The shrimp were the smallest baby shrimp Ive ever seen!! A few ants could carry one away. The mussels marinara had baby mussels! Marinara sauce was decent. I know they have an awesome marinated chicken foccacia sandwich that I would absolutely recommend, but never any of their dinners! Matter of fact, we should have seen the red flags when we found out it was pasta night and NO ONE was there. BOOOOOOOOO!!!! Wish I could give 1/2....no 1/16 star :o(
DA
Darrick
Pizza is actually pretty good , its definitely not the best pizza even in the area. My my complaint is because of the rude Italian guy who always has a stupid attitude if you pay bycredit. He should be happy someones even coming back for horrible service like his , on top of that the place is dusty , he charges fkr food u didnt even get and I never knew a cheese pizza is speciality and he can charge almost 19 bucks for it , that crazy. Basically pizza is average and specifically that 1 guys servous is disgusting. I strongly recommend you find somewhere else 2 eat.
A
A Private User
Everyone who is writing reviews expect perfection. None of you know what the idea of perfection is until you eat here. You attempt to try garlic knots from another pizzaria and you will find out for certain that the Stelton Pizza is best known. Everything they do is made with heart and soul and the taste of the food surely shows it. All of you are wrong for the feeble attempts at a correct review. Yay for Stelton and long live a wonderful and hopefully long lived career.
KE
Kevin Dudek
Seriously the BEST damn pizza out there! If you havent tried it yet ... you dont know what really good pizza is! I was in the Navy and traveled a lot, had pizza all across the USA and around the world and nothing compares! Been a steady customer now going on 18+ years! Im there at least once a week and its So good that I always make sure that I have extra in my freezer!!
MA
Matthew Pfancook
My grandfather took us to Stelton Pizza when we were visiting from Pa. It was some of the best Pizza i have ever had. The service was great and everyone was very friendly, which creates a warm atmosphere. I would definitely eat at Stelton Pizza if giving the chance again. I give them 4 stars.
MO
mohit tilva
This is one of the best local restaurants in this area. Its a huge menu including pizza, pasta, subs, sandwiches, soups and more. Its really quite in the evenings and night and I like that. My favorite is mushroom focaccia sandwich and portobello salad with red bell peppers.
J
J Mayrides
My food might have been good, but I will never know because I never got it. They never delivered it and said it was pickup even though we told them an address and asked for delivery. This place is terrible. Take your business elsewhere. I would give 0 stars if I could.
HE
Heather Morrison
My husband and I went here for lunch. Our first time here, we got a house salad, 2 slices of pepperoni pizza and a molten chocolate cake. This is going to be a regular stop for lunch for us each week we are up here. Everything was very good.
A
A Private User
Just thinking of it makes my mouth water! Stelton Pizza is delicious! The pies are a bit small, but they are so worth it!!!!!!! The prices are reasonable, like KTKC said. Conveniently located, this is an excellent pizzeria.
CO
Coady Egan
Seems like a good local pizza shop. Its very low key and inexpensive, but the pizza and salad was fresh and tasted great. It has a casual atmosphere to it and is very comfortable to stop and have a quick dinner
SR
Srivatsan Sundararajan
Pizzas are brilliant. One of the best I have had. I love the Vodka Sauce and the plain slices. Other favs from this place are eggplant parm hero, ravioli, grillled portabella sandwich, baked ziti
ST
Steven Cohen
Great pizza, friendly staff. Be sure to stop in and try it - eat in BYOB or take it home Ive been going here since they opened - probably 15 years. The only true pizza according to my kids
VI
Victor Catalino
Ordered whole pie, pizza was soggy, dough was thin, great sauce though. Also had shrimp salad, only had six very overcooked, microwaved even, shrimp. Will never order a pie from here again.
ST
Steve Sperry
I am a truck driver. I was at Halls refrigeration warehouse. Went on the internet and found this place called them for pizza . I got the works. Best damn pizza I ever ate! Bar none!
RM
rmac362
They have a great selection of Italian foods besides the excellent pizza. There is a good sized seating area if you want to sit down to enjoy your food instead of take out.
DE
Devon McDonough
All food is great, not really the best place for table service type eating, as few do it, but solid nonetheless. I eat here several times a month and its always consistent!
LI
lisa alexander
Ive always had a good experience with stelton road pizza...i moved down here from bergen county, n i couldnt find good pizza until i tasted theirs...
HE
Heather McAllister
The Pizza is great, especially the eggplant, but its not worth putting up with the impolite front desk employees or the rude pizza chefs.
VI
Vincent Cardwell
Crust was over cooked and still doughy, ingredients were scarce , wings no bueno. Cost too much for all this suckyness !!!
MA
marc sunny
It was a dirty place. The bald guy was making pizza with dirty hands. It was disgusting. I will never go that hell again.
A
A Private User
They have great service, reasonable prices, excellent menu with many varried options. Great people and great resturant.
CA
Calvin Womack
My wife loves the buffalo chicken pizza. I just love there pizza in general. Also the staff has always been nice.
MI
Mit Kalola
Food: Pizza is average. Service: OK. Not too friendly. I have eaten here many times. Pizza is not that great.
A
A Private User
I have been going here since they opened and I love their pizza. It is a family regular for Friday nights.
CA
Cameron Hackett
If your looking for an authentic pizzeria, with amazing service. This is your place!! Good, clean eating.
AN
Anupam Sheth
I would rate their pizza a four. But the service is very friendly. And they have karaoke.
MA
Mark R
Best chicken foccacia, best italian hot dog, one of the best cheese steaks and pizza.
FR
Frank Pulgiano
Average pizza....so Ive been told. Try for yourself and give a better rating.
LO
Louis Fevrin
Best Pizza in Piscataway bar none when i moved hear went to them all
JO
Jon Nagel
my calzone was over cooked ... it took way too long to come out
A
A Private User
People are great. Food is good. Pizza is ok. Price is ok.
ME
Mehul Vora
Ok pizza.
BR
Brandon Wingo
My familys been a steady customer for many many years
IA
Ian Mugoya
Great Pizza lots of options. I cant wait to go back.
A
A Private User
Great place. Clean. Fast service. Great food!
DO
Douglas Pein
Chicken Foccacia sandwich is AWESOME!!!!
J
J Smith
One of the best pizzas out there.
KI
Kirstin Lutz
Fresh bacon on their bacon pizza
MU
Mudit Gupta
Excellent plain pizza slices.
BE
Ben West
Their pizza is pretty good.
A
A Private User
Good vodka pizza mmm...
JO
Johnpaul_7777 christ_follower
Great steak sandwich
CE
Cecelia Daly
Fast service
KI
Kittyisadork
Great pizza!
JO
John Shotliff
Good pizza!
RU
Russell Meier
Great pizza
AN
Andrew Unglert
Great food
JO
John Aquino
Good food
