Address: | 3350 E 51st St, Tulsa, OK 74135, USA |
Phone: | +1 918-743-7761 |
Site: | mariostulsa.com |
Rating: | 4.2 |
Working: | Closed 11AM–2PM 11AM–2PM 11AM–2PM 11AM–2PM 11AM–9PM 4–8PM |
AN
Anthony Fiallo
I am a transplant, from the tri-state area. I know what NY pizza taste like, I grew up on it, and this is the closet place I have found here in Tulsa. Great sauce nice atmosphere(reminds me of an actual pizzeria) and a good selection of food found in a NY pizzeria. However a single slice is 2.25 and a large Sicilian pie is 16.25 and 1.50 per topping. Not to mention the size defference in a regular pie and sicilian pie from NY to here. I know back home in NY/NJ I can get a coke and a slice for 2.00 I also know that a large Sicilian pie with pepperoni is about 12 bucks and is bigger than what is served here. I remember being back i n NY and every Friday was pizza day and we could get a 2ltr of coke and a pie delivered for about 12 dollars. This place is expensive but if you are visiting and need a taste for some good NY pizza this is the place to come.
A
A Private User
Ordered a large 1/2 Pepperoni 1/2 Cheese (extra sauce, extra cheese) for takeout. I was told my pizza was to big for the large box and they had put it in the X-large box (no complaints here). Upon opening the box I was impressed with the mammoth pizza before me. There was indeed extra sauce and extra cheese...the flavor and freshness of the toppings were very good. The flavor of the crust really popped. I can not think of another pizza place whose crust compares. The combination of sauce, topping, and crust makes this my new favorite pizza place. My mouth is watering just thinking about it! Can not wait to go back and try some other things on the menu!
A
A Private User
authentic for sure just the NY attitude. Called from my cell phone and got the number off an app that did not specify the location I was calling. So I called and when they picked up I asked if this was the location close to harvard by food pyramid, Well after I was greeted and asked the question the person on he other end hung up. But no problem across the highway from the marios I was looking for is new york pizza. It is great itailin food with great customer service highly reccomend people trying NY pizza in tulsa.
SE
Sean McCoy
Stopped in because we wanted pizza and it happened to be right where we were. The pizza was great - and the service was wonderful. I asked if I could get a chicken parmigiana with no sauce for our toddler since he doesnt really like pizza. They brought it out already sliced into strips for him. That impressed the heck out of me - a very simple, incredibly thoughtful thing for them to do. Won us over BIG time.
CR
Crystal Davis
This place is very so so...Its edible but it doesnt take you away delicious. As this was my first time here we decided to try it based on the good reviews our go to pizza place was closed on Sunday . For 1.50 each topping I felt like I got way to little than I should have. Pizza was mostly soggy bread with scarce bits of meat and maybe a piece of onion on a slice.
DA
David H.
Not sure why this place has such great reviews. The best pizza in Tulsa is Umbertos on 21st & Harvard. This Marios place is closer to us so we decided to pick up a pie after shopping next door at Reasors. Its not bad but its not even close to as good as Umbertos. Also, their large is only a 16". WTF??? 3 stars at best.
RU
Russ Braaten
I am from NYC and got hooked the first time I got a pie and meatball sub from Mario. I was worried the food would decline when we lost him but it hasnt one bit. I live in OKC and once drove to Tulsa just to get my Marios fix. Sadly I have a funeral to go to in Tulsa next week but I will be stopping by Marios.
CR
craig albrecht
This was my first dining experience at this pizzeria and to be quite honest I wasnt impressed. I feel for the price the taste and ingredients are lacking. Not much flavor to the pizza pies whatsoever. I dont think Ill be back too this location again price doesnt justify what you get for your money.
JE
Jeff Pegg
I used to come here all the time and loved it. The last 3 times Ive come by have been around 7:45 or 8:00. They arent willing to make slices "this close till close". What kind of a restaurant that likes its customer wont make food? I highly recommend going around the corner to NYC pizza.
A
A Private User
We have been loyal customers of Marios for years...and for very good reason! Since we moved to Kansas City and then Rhode Island we dont get Marios very often, but we make sure to stop in anytime that we are in town. Great place! There should be six stars to rate the food!
PH
Phil Camuso
Having lived on and recently moved from the East Coast/NYC area, we were worried about being able to get good Italian eats. Hands down, this is the best pizza in Tulsa. So far, no other place has even come close to reminding us of home!
JO
Jonathan Swafford
Good NYC style pizza with a nice homemade crust. Pricing is good and offers by the slice or full pies. The staff is friendly and fast. The decor leaves a lot to be desired. All and all not a bad place to grab a quick slice.
TA
Tara Hogue
Nasty pizza place Ive ever been to. I order a spaghetti the sauce had no taste I order mushroom it was canned and I order meatballs with it. The guy told me it was beef but it wasnt. I really dont know what it was.
GU
Gustavo Schaeffer
The calzone is very tasty and filled with lots of cheese. Not the nicest place as far as decoration and ambience but when it comes to food this place has one of the best pizzas and calzones we have ever eaten.
GR
Grady Postrach
They have amazing pizza to die for, but thats not even the best part about this wonderful business they are very very very nice people and they are very good at keeping their customers happy!!
ST
Steve Melton
This place has the best pizza in Tulsa it is traditional New York style pizza is very awesome delicious pizza they have a nice menu with anything Italian that you want very awesome place
DA
Dana Dobias
BEST Pizza! We eat here all the time! We even brought family visiting from NYC, not only did they ask to come back a second time, they also said its better pizza than they get in N.Y.!
AM
Amber Washington
We moved right next door to this place and had no idea how good it was. Now we eat here almost once a week! We highly recommend the calzone! So far the best weve found in Tulsa.
JA
Jake Ledgerwood
Despite having decent pizza, their employees rudeness makes it unbearable. I dont really want to give my hard earned money to people who could care less.
JE
Jennifer Garcia
Love this place the pizza is awsome and delicious. My kids dont like pizza but love MARIOS. I would definately recommend this place to all my friends.
DA
David Helm
Pizza is good and authentic New York style, but what I really like is their Meatball sub, fresh-baked bread, great meatballs. Really good.
BR
Brent Furgeson
Felt it was over priced for what you get I dont mind paying $20-30 for a pizza but in that price range it better blow me away.