My Sugar Pie

Address:	40 E Pine St, Zionsville, IN 46077, USA
Phone:	+1 317-733-8717
Site:	mysugarpie.com
Rating:	4.6
Working:	10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 10AM–6PM 7AM–3PM Closed

Location

Photos 88

Reviews 20

Ryan Galbraith

Website was not up and they didnt answer the phone so I drove up from greenwood. My mistake for thinking I would at least be greeted with a smile. Instead it was a quick we are sold out and a funny look. I felt uncomfortable and as I write this I feel more uncomfortable due to all the good reviews. This is my first bad review of any company. I will kiss this $25 gift certificate good buy and help your bottom line and you can have this review in trade.

C Germain

I have never found a better pie. The crust is flakey and the pies are wonderful. I have been buying pies from Kelly when she was making them at home and selling them at the farmers market. When I say the pies are great, they all are because, I have had every pie that Kelly makes. Favorite Strawberry Rhubarb, but they all are great.

Tyler Merrick

Excellent pies, fancy little shop with too many choices to pick from and by that I mean I want to eat them all. A few small little tables to enjoy a slice of pie and some coffee. Pies may be ordered in advanced / whole pies picked up, the come in a nice box and include a nice glass pie dish.

Cynde Marcus

Great pie place. You can walk in for a piece of pie where they usually have about 6 different pies that change from day to day . However, the best is there many, many flavors that can to ordered ahead and many can be made with special requests like sugar free!

A Private User

The pies are the best I have ever tasted. I am not really a pie person because I usually do not like the crust but their crust is so good!!! You need to try it and you will be hooked.

Nicole Beatty

Had one slice from them at the Noblesville farmers market. Best pie this cake lover has had hands down. Perfection!

Laura Huffman

OMG....sugar overload in an amazing way! The sugar cream pie is amazing. Putting in my order for the holidays now!

Tom Lang

Ive eaten pies all around the country. This is probably one of the best apple pies I ever tasted.

Jim Yarnell

pies was extremely good and the baker answer questions without hesitation which is always nice

Mike Noirot

These pies are fantastic. I havent found one that I didnt like from here.

Rhianna Latshaw

The Cherry pie is amazing! Actually all of their its are amazing!